A Northwestern Basketball Fan's Open Letter to the NCAA
Dear National Collegiate Athletic Association,
What the hell are you thinking?
Ninety-six teams in the NCAA Tournament? At long last, have you no sense of decency?
This is the worst idea since Plaxico Burress thought it would be fun to bring a loaded gun into a night club.
You're going to wind up shooting yourself in the proverbial leg.
Right now, it's an honor for teams to be one of the select 65 of the 347 D1 basketball schools to be chosen for "The Big Dance."
Expanding it to 96 teams would turn "The Big Dance" into "The Bloated Dance."
According to Dictionary.com, the second definition of bloated is "excessively vain, conceited."
March Madness has been so successful, you think you can capitalize on America's love of sports by expanding the tournament so you can make more $$$.
Sorry, but even Americans have their limits when it comes to indulging in super-sized stuff. There's a reason why Burger King hasn't made anything bigger than the Quad Stacker.
Do we really want to see No. 1 Kentucky play No. 24 Podunk University? It's bad enough watching one seeds destroy 16 seeds every year. Americans love rooting for the underdog, but expanding the field to 96 teams would completely eliminate the first round upset.
Even if you gave the top teams byes to avoid such public executions, it would still rule out any huge upsets early in the tourney.
If you had a bunch of so-called play-in games to narrow things down, no one but alums of the schools involved would watch. Right now you have one play-in game that no one watches—creating more isn't going to do much good.
The current format is perfect, with the exception of the 1-16 game, anything can happen. Northwestern State, the 14 seed that stunned No. 3 Iowa a few years back? With 96 teams, assuming no byes or play-in games, they'd be slight underdogs against the No. 11 seed.
That's not fun at all.
Now, you might assume that because I'm a fan of the only school in the so-called "Power Six Conferences" that's never made the NCAA Tournament that I'd be a supporter of this expansion idea.
Nope.
Northwestern making a 96-team field would not be special at all. This isn't tee ball; you don't get a trophy for participation. Plus, the stigma of having never made the tournament back when it meant something to make the tournament would forever be tattooed on our logo.
Also, you think the regular season is ignored by most of America now? Wait until you expand the tournament.
Now, my friend Stephen Woldenberg thinks this is much ado about nothing, and ESPN's Andy Katz seems to agree.
Katz makes the point that the commissioners of the "Power Six" conferences would have to approve your crackpot idea. Big Ten commissioner Jim Delany, bless his heart, has already come out against expansion (of the tournament, not the conference, that is a whole different story).
But the fact that it's even being seriously considered by people as high-up as the Vice President of your organization is an outrage.
Put a stop to this insanity now, so we can still enjoy March Madness in the years to come.
Sincerely,
Aaron Morse