Anybody who watches HBO’s 24/7 series on the upcoming Miguel Cotto versus Antonio Margarito fight should know that the main point of contention and animosity is, whether or not Antonio Margarito wore illegal hand wraps in their previous fight three years ago.
Miguel Cotto has stated numerous times that based on the outcome of their previous fight, and photographs of Margarito’s hand wraps that he believes Margarito did wear illegal hand wraps. Margarito has responded to Cotto’s accusations in an offended tone by belittling Cotto as a crybaby who makes excuses for his shortcomings.
Yet, isn’t it conventional wisdom to think that there is a good possibility Margarito did wear illegal wraps in his previous fight against Miguel Cotto, where he was the underdog? If Margarito attempted to wear plaster-like wraps in his following fight with Shane Mosley, even though he was the favorite to win?
Regardless of whether he did or didn’t wear illegal wraps against Cotto in 2008; Margarito needs to get used to the fact that there will always be a shadow of doubt cast over the legitimacy of all his wins previous to the Shane Mosley fight. It is a fact that he attempted to wear hardened plaster-like wraps against Mosley. The world has not been given a reason to believe Margarito’s claims that he is a clean fighter, who abided by all the rules prior to his encounter with Mosley.
The only way that Margarito can start to heal his reputation in the eyes of the fans is through complete and total absolution. He could learn a lot from boxers that have been in his position, like Luis Resto.
During the late 70s and early 80s, Luis Resto was a New York journeyman welterweight that had some talent. He also had a reputation as a light puncher. In 31 fights he only had eight KOs. During his career he compiled a record of 20-8-2 with one No Contest. He wasn’t nearly as talented a fighter as Antonio Margarito. His connection to Margarito unfolds in the tale of his one No Contest decision against up-and-comer Billy Collins Jr.
When Billy Collins Jr. met Luis Resto on June 16th, 1983, he was a young 22-year-old fighter with an impressive record of 14-0 and 11 KOs. Billy Collins Jr. was the overwhelming favorite. Luis Resto was only supposed to be a stepping stone, which is why the events of that night were a shock to everybody.
Luis Resto appeared to have made monumental gains in strength, and beat poor Billy Collins Jr.’s face to the point of being unrecognizable. Despite the brutal beating, Billy was able to stay on his feet en route to what was originally an unanimous decision loss. It was after the fight when Billy Collins Sr., Jr.’s father and trainer, went to go congratulate Luis Resto that he discovered Resto’s gloves felt way too light and sparsely padded. Ultimately, Resto’s gloves were confiscated.
To make a long story short, padding was removed from the gloves. Luis Resto and his trainer, Panama Lewis, were both suspended by the New York State Athletic Commission indefinitely. Just like the Margarito hand wrap scandal, both trainer and fighter were held accountable as they should be. Also, like the Margarito scandal, both fighter and trainer denied any misconduct. Up until this point the stories seem very similar, but then they start to diverge a bit.
The New York State Athletic Commission took a hard stance against the behavior of Resto and Lewis. Luis Resto would never be allowed to box again. His trainer Panama Lewis would never be able to work the corner of a professional fight.
Javier Capetillo, who was Antonio Margarito’s trainer during the Mosley fight, may never corner a professional fight again. If he never does, then justice on one part would be served. But, what about Antonio Margarito’s future as a professional fighter? Margarito was suspended from boxing for a year. A little over a year after the Mosley fight, he was in the ring fighting Manny Pacquiao for the World Boxing Council light middleweight title. Is this justice?
I understand that Antonio Margarito and Luis Resto weren’t in identical situations; however, there are strong parallels. Margarito was caught with loaded hand wraps before his fight with Mosley, not after like Luis Resto. Yet, Margarito’s intentions were the same as Resto’s. Doesn’t that warrant a harsher penalty than a one-year suspension?
Luis Resto may have been able to return to boxing if it wasn’t for the unfortunate aftermath of his bout with Collins Jr. Resto’s cheating resulted in Collins receiving a severe permanent eye injury that would end his boxing career. Without boxing in his life, Billy Collins Jr. fell into a deep depression. He started to abuse alcohol, which later lead to his death. Less than a year after his fight with Resto, Billy Collins Jr. died in a car accident as a consequence of drunk driving. It is believed Resto's cheating destroyed the life of Billy Collins Jr.
Resto eventually was tried for assault, and spent over two years in prison for his actions in the ring. All the while maintaining his story of how his gloves were tampered with. Finally, he publicly confessed his guilt in 2008, which is profiled in the documentary Assault in the Ring.
He also admitted that he used plaster of Paris wraps in addition to having padding removed from his gloves. In the documentary, Resto expresses guilt and remorse for his wrongdoing. He proved that he had a conscience. He allowed his guilt to supersede his pride. I wish Margarito would do the same.
Miguel Cotto believes that Margarito used illegal wraps in their last fight, and there is no reason why he shouldn’t. Margarito acknowledges no remorse for his past misdeeds, and he has taken no responsibility whatsoever for them. Right now, Antonio Margarito is lying in order to protect his pride and honor just like Luis Resto did. Fortunately for Margarito, he was never caught with illegal wraps immediately after a fight. That is the only reason why he is currently licensed to box, and not in jail like Luis Resto. But again, has justice been served?
Antonio Margarito is no better than Luis Resto. He attempted to wear illegal wraps before the Mosley fight for the same reason Resto wore them for the Collins fight. The only difference is that he got caught before the fight. Even if he beats Cotto legitimately, that doesn’t account for his past transgressions. I hope he learns from Luis Resto and confesses his guilt. It would show the world that he has a conscience and some character. All he is showing now is that he is a shameless liar that cares more about his pride than the welfare of others. Until Antonio Margarito confesses his guilt in the hand wrapping scandal, he will never have any integrity in the sport of boxing or outside of it.