BYU vs. Boise State: Game Grades, Analysis for Cougars and Broncos

The Boise State Broncos have never lost at home on a Friday night, and that didn't change in a 55-30 drubbing of BYU that wasn't as close as the final score indicated.
Boise State dominated on both offense and defense en route to the victory, as you can tell in the below game grades for both teams.
Positional Unit | First-Half Grade | Final Grade |
---|---|---|
Pass Offense | A | A- |
Run Offense | B | B+ |
Pass Defense | B | B+ |
Run Defense | B- | B |
Special Teams | B+ | B+ |
Coaching | A- | A- |
Pass Offense: Boise State quarterback Grant Hedrick had a career-best day in many capacities, going 24-of-31 with 410 yards, one interception and five total touchdowns—four through the air. He threaded the needle with a couple of deep balls, but it was largely the speed and separation ability of his receivers that ran up those passing totals.
Run Offense: Boise State’s fanbase held its collective breath when Jay Ajayi looked injured after conceding a safety, but they exhaled after seeing him return to punishing defenders. He finished with 26 carries for 118 yards and two touchdowns, constantly blowing over BYU’s defense. The Cougars stacked the box early to frustrate Ajayi, and it didn’t work one bit.

Pass Defense: The holes are still there in Boise State’s secondary, but they’re a lot less glaring when the defensive line is generating pressure. The Broncos’ front was treacherous on Friday, chasing Christian Stewart around all game long. They slipped up once and it was a big one—an 81-yard touchdown—but it was an otherwise strong outing from the unit.
Run Defense: BYU’s offensive success was few and far between, but Jamaal Williams’ rushing success was one bright spot. He had a number of punishing runs including a 17-yard touchdown, but Boise State held him in check other than that. After grabbing an early lead, BYU didn’t run the ball much, anyway.
Special Teams: Boise State punter Sean Wale wasn’t on the field very much early, and that’s a promising sign. The Broncos made the plays when opportunities came up, recovering a botched punt return in the first quarter. Kicker Dan Goodale was perfect on extra points and 2-of-2 in field goals.
Coaching: Like they're known to do, Boise State's coaches orchestrated the trickery with a first-quarter pitch-and-pass that went for a touchdown. They constantly drew up pressure to frustrate BYU's passing game, and kept Boise State's offense ahead of the chains.
Positional Unit | First-Half Grade | Final Grade |
---|---|---|
Pass Offense | C+ | C+ |
Run Offense | B- | B- |
Pass Defense | D | D+ |
Run Defense | B- | C+ |
Special Teams | C | C+ |
Coaching | C+ | C+ |
Pass Offense: BYU quarterback Stewart was rarely protected in the pocket and when he was, he struggled to find the mark. He went 23-of-38 for 259 yards, overthrowing a couple of receivers and failing to make plays when the Cougars needed a spark. His 81-yard strike to Colby Pearson seemed to open things up early on, but Boise State’s defense tightened.
Run Offense: Williams was a small glimmer of light in an otherwise paltry performance overall from BYU. He ran 16 times for 70 yards. If the Cougars weren’t down so much in the second half, Williams would have put up even bigger numbers. But it’s no secret that without Taysom Hill around, this rushing offense is a shell of what it used to be.

Pass Defense: BYU has hidden its speed deficiency in the secondary against many of its opponents, but not Friday night against the electric Boise State offense. The Cougars’ secondary was gashed for 410 yards through the air, giving up everything from deep balls down the field to screen passes for chunk yardage.
Run Defense: After Ajayi's first rush of the game went for 17 yards, his next five went for just seven yards combined. But instead of continuing to bottle up the talented rusher, Ajayi emerged with 26 carries for 118 yards and two touchdowns.
Special Teams: BYU's early botched punt return only cost them three points, but it set the tone for a poor special teams day. The Cougars' three punt returns went for just 13 total yards, and Scott Arellano punted eight times—never a good thing.
Coaching: Head coach Bronco Mendenhall put his trust in his defense against the odds before the first half ended and it paid off with a safety. Other than that, though, BYU's coaching staff rarely put the offense in a position to succeed.