Ireland Defeat Exposes Italy's Lack of Depth

The group stage of the 2016 UEFA European Championship came to a close on Wednesday. The final games on the slate came from Group E, and they provided ample drama. Both matches were decided by goals in the last 10 minutes, and the contest between Italy and the Republic of Ireland saw the latter qualify for the round of 16 in dramatic fashion with a 1-0 victory.
The Italians came into the game having already won the group. There were some who thought that may not have been the best of things. If the Azzurri had come in as runners-up, they would have ended up playing the winner of Group F—the weakest in the tournament—in the round of 16. That turned out to be Hungary, followed by a potential quarterfinal against either Wales or Northern Ireland.
Winning the group set up a date with the runner-up of Group D. After two rounds it was generally assumed that that would be Croatia—until the Vatreni turned the tournament on its ear with a last-gasp win over Spain on Tuesday. That gave them top spot in the group—and set up a marquee matchup between Italy and Spain on Monday.
With the next round's opponents set, Wednesday's match with the Irish was little more than a formality for Italy. It gave manager Antonio Conte the chance to heavily rotate his squad, giving a measure of rest to key players who had run hard for two games and a chance for less-used figures to make an impression. The reserves made an impression all right—but it wasn't the one most of them would have wanted to make.
Some of the changes were forced or semi-forced. Antonio Candreva, who has manned Conte's right wing with aplomb in this tournament, sustained a hamstring injury in Friday's match against Sweden. While his fitness is being considered day-to-day, there was no way the Lazio man would play in a meaningless game.

Similarly rested was goalkeeper and captain Gianluigi Buffon, who had been dealing with an illness. Had this game mattered, he likely would have played. In his absence, Salvatore Sirigu deputized, though the rust from losing his starting job at Paris Saint-Germain would be painfully obvious in this match.
Conte made six more changes to the lineup, including both strikers and both wing-backs. Alessandro Florenzi was moved from the wing to the center of midfield, along with first-time starters Thiago Motta and Stefano Sturaro.
Adjusting the defense was a pickle for Conte. The back three have been Italy's bedrock in France, but two of them—Leonardo Bonucci and Giorgio Chiellini—picked up yellow cards in the group opener against Belgium. Another booking for either would mean that the player would be suspended for the game against Spain.
The conundrum: Conte had decided to only take one reserve center-back to France. Angelo Ogbonna played in place of Chiellini, but Bonucci would play the entire 90 minutes. The 29-year-old has been Italy's star man in this tournament—losing his combination of defensive and passing abilities could well have been fatal.
Bonucci described the situation to Sky Sport Italia (h/t Football Italia) as having "a Sword of Damocles over your head," and he came perilously close to picking up that fateful card. However, he got through the match, leading the back line to a good performance that was only marred at the end.
The same couldn't be said of the midfield and forward lines. Presented with what amounted to an audition for more playing time in the knockout stage, the Italians almost universally flopped.
The midfield in particular was putrid. Motta could not control the game from the regista position. Florenzi was unable to use his dribbling ability to take on Irish defenders. Sturaro did well when he played his game, but sometimes he tried to play outside himself and paid for it by getting dispossessed.
One part of the midfield's problem was out of their control.
The pitch at the Stade Pierre-Mauroy in Lille was absolutely atrocious. Bad weather in the area did so much damage to the pitch that UEFA announced on Tuesday, per the Associated Press (h/t ESPN FC), that they would replace the turf after the group stage was over.
It was worth wondering whether Conte was having flashbacks to 2013, when his Juventus team crashed out of the UEFA Champions League on a snow-blasted pitch in Istanbul.

The surface made passing difficult, but this midfield combination could have been playing on AstroTurf and struggled to provide service to strikers Ciro Immobile and Simone Zaza, such was the dearth of ideas when Italy managed to keep possession.
Zaza and Immobile did their best with what they had—which wasn't much at all. Besides the lack of opportunities, the two strikers are too similar to play together. Zaza managed to change the game against Sweden, bringing a pace that Graziano Pelle lacked, but he can't be relied on to provide all the speed in attack.
He dovetailed well with Eder on Friday and improved when Lorenzo Insigne was inserted into Wednesday's game in the 74th minute. But he should never be deployed with Immobile again.
Insigne, on the other hand, was one of the game's few bright spots. His introduction immediately gave the Azzurri an element of danger they had totally lacked before then. Three minutes after coming on he skipped past the Irish defense and unleashed a curling shot that slammed into the base of the post.
Ireland hadn't created that many high-level opportunities in the second half, but with six minutes left on the clock they created the two best of the night.
Bonucci was in possession in the defensive third when he was mugged by Wes Hoolahan. Referee Ovidiu Hategan of Romania, who called 40 total fouls and generally killed the rhythm of the game by constantly blowing his whistle for soft infringements, deigned to let Ireland play on in this case, but Sirigu managed to win the one-on-one duel.
A minute later, though, Hoolahan was back at it, swinging in a dangerous cross toward Robbie Brady. The Norwich City man got a free header and sent Ireland into ecstasy.
The goal was a product of Italy's squad rotation. Bonucci, who was marking Brady, has played with Buffon for six years, and it was obvious by his body language that he was expecting the goalkeeper to come out to play the ball, but Sirigu stopped short and Brady did the rest.

At the end of the day, this game was meaningless for the Italians. They had only two objectives going in: for everyone to come out healthy and for Bonucci to avoid a yellow card. Both of those things came to pass. For all their failings on Wednesday, this game will have little effect on the round-of-16 game against Spain.
Only two of the players on the field Wednesday figure to start against La Roja—Barzagli and Bonucci. Buffon will return and the "BBC" defense will be reunited. Daniele De Rossi will return to steady the midfield, while Pelle and Eder will return to lead the attack.
If this game has any takeaways, it's that Conte needs those people on the field. The only person in this game to make a legitimate case for playing time was Insigne. The rest showed just how steep the drop-off in team cohesion is when the second unit moves in.
Italy now have five days to prepare for their crunch game with the two-time defending European champions.
There may be things to learn from the Ireland match from a tactical standpoint, but if Italy's overall performance felt like it usually does in a friendly, that's because that's pretty much what the game was for them.
When the Italy starters return to the field, fans will most likely get treated to the best game of the round of 16.