It was a night of high-drama at Somerset Park as incident followed incident. By the end of the game, there was elation; well for the Ayr United fans anyway.
After three painful defeats in recent weeks for Brian Reid's Ayr side, things looked bleak for the home team as they headed into this Communities Cup match against Scotland's third force, Heart of Midlothian.
Ayr United have a good recent record against SPL sides with notable wins against St Mirren preseason, Hibs in the cup last season and numerous victories over the auld enemy from up the road.
Although their recent mini slump was fresh in the memory of the players, they didn't let it affect their mental state as they prepped for the "Big" match.
Talk over the recent weeks for the Ayr fans had been focused on the returning Ryan Stevenson, but disappointment was to befell the midfielder. Stevenson found himself out of the running for not only a starting spot, but also a place on the bench. The player himself had stated recently that should he score against his old side, he would not celebrate. Got to love the loyalty there from him.
After last night's surprise win for East Fife over Aberdeen, Hearts were not in the mood to become another SPL scalp taken by a lower league club and were well aware of Ayr's big game hunting over the past years. So, they started with big shooters Skacel and Sutton up top to try and kill the Honest Men off, but the Somerset Park hoodoo is not one that shall be distinguished easily by any SPL side.
With all the victories that lower league teams shower upon the so called big guns, it makes a mockery of the power brokers of Scottish football that the top tier can't be expanded due to lack of competition but that's a story for another day.
Tonight though belonged to the terraces of the old lady of Scottish football and her new lights.
It was the visiting Edinburgh side that plied all the early pressure with Novikovas flying down the left wing with relative ease, pinging crosses in with stunning consistency, and it didn't take long for the first real effort on Kevin Cuthbert's goa. However, a superb dive down to his left kept the ball from bulging the net and set the scene for what could have been a long night for the stopper.
Ayr were limited to counter attacks at this point but surprisingly had the better of the chances over the next 10 minutes with efforts from Trouten, Moffat and Wardlaw all going close. Just minutes before the half time whistle, McKernon was unlucky not to connect properly with the ball after Wardlaw cleverly stepped over and dummied the ball, opening up space for the ex St Mirren man. He watched as his effort spun high and away from the danger zone.
Ayr started brightly in the second half with Wardlaw trying an audacious effort from 40 yards out after catching a glimpse of open goal with Janos Balogh 10 yards out from the goal line, but the big striker's effort drifted over.
Hearts got lucky just four minutes into the half as a corner dropped to an unmarked Scott Robinson on the edge of the box. His shot managed to squirm its way through the defender's legs and seemed to roll unsighted into the corner of Cuthbert's goal to give the Tynecastle side the lead.
Ayr were unlucky just moments later as the ever resourceful Michael McGowan whipped in wicked corner kick that seemed to agonisingly curl past the back post as Ayr players scrambled to get a touch on it.
Ayr had to make a tactical substitution just nine minutes into the second as veteran stopper John Robertson left the field injured. Due to low squad numbers, 19-year-old Ross Robertson filled into a makeshift defender's role despite being a midfielder. However, the youngster performed admirably throughout the remainder of the game, thwarting several opportunities by the attacking Hearts side.
In a moment of controversy in the 61st minute, Hearts bundled the ball into the goal, and the players wheeled away in delight as they appeared to have taken a two-goal lead. Although the referee pointed to the centre spot acknowledging the goal, he was summoned by the assistant referee on the far side as the Ayr players demanded that the decision be overruled for a handball incident.
After much deliberation the referee reversed his decision and yellow carded Eggert Jonsson for allegedly punching the ball into the goal.
The relief on Brian Reid's face was apparent to the watching Ayr fans and from this moment, Ayr took the initiative. Through pressure, Wardlw managed to intercept a scuffed clearance to slot home from 18 yards, much to the delight of the Somerset Road end fans.
The big attacker had been immense throughout this match, using his experience to muscle, pressure and push his opponents defenders to breaking point.
With their tails up, Ayr were playing well at this point, McGowan in particular causing all sorts of problems for the defenders with every pass, every turn and every run. Ayr got lucky halfway through the half when Cuthbert was called upon to save a point blank shot to keep his side on level terms.
Sutton and Templeton had a couple of half chances for the visitors before the end of the 90 minutes, and McGowan was again unlucky for the home side when his whipped-in corner had to be cleared from the near post by the hand of Hearts stopper Balogh.
As the final whistle was blown for the end of the 90 minutes, the heavens opened as if to douse the flames of optimism that either side had in finishing the match in regular time, but extra time beckoned. Few would argue that the full-time SPL side would surely hold the advantage regards fitness. This was to prove a fruitless thought, as it were the part-time Ayrshire side that bolted from the gates in extra time with a couple of chances early on from McKernon and Moffat sailing wide.
Hearts were to dominate the remainder of the first period of extra time with only a couple of respites for the Ayr defensive backline. Right at the death of this first 15 minutes, Hearts' Ryan McGowan went down in the box claiming to be felled, but the nearside assistant referee was unimpressed and waved play away much to the big Australian's disbelief.
The second half of extra time was to prove a more matched affair with both sides having opportunities to score the winner, but when the referee's whistle shrilled at the end, no one could argue that penalties were the least that both sides deserved.
The lottery of penalties was upon us. As the players and keepers headed to the away end in front of the Hearts fans, Ayr's Michael Moffat stepped up first to score for the home side with Eggert Jonsson equalized for the away team.
However, this was to be Hearts' only penalty goal as they watched McKernon and Trouten step up to keep the Ayr ball rolling. The SPL side's next penalty efforts from Grainger and Skacel were brilliantly saved by Cuthbert in goal, and it was left to Mark Roberts to fire the final nail in the coffin of the Scottish capital side's cup dreams.
The final penalty sparked elation amongst the Ayr fans, who promptly invaded the pitch to celebrate the victory with their heroes once again.
Hearts boss Paulo Sergio was adamant afterwards that the disallowed goal should have stood claiming that the assistant ref had ran 30 yards back toward the halfway line, a claim that no one else had apparently seen, but the man in charge is entitled to his opinion.
Kevin Cuthbert also spoke about the incident and the part he played in getting the decision reversed. He was fairly open about what he saw or didn't see. The stopper wasn't sure of the handball by the Hearts man but claimed it all the same in a protest to the referee that saw the decision reversed in his favour.
Brian Reid said that his players effort and commitment from a part-time squad was terrific and even when they lost John Robertson, he had faith in the young backline that was left to defend his side from defeat. He is also looking forward to the draw tomorrow hoping, for a favourable home draw.
One thing is for sure, Ayr will not be a draw that any other club will savour.
All remaining clubs are now looking at the prospect of two more wins in is competition. They will be in the final and with Rangers, Aberdeen and now Hearts all out of the running, it gives a lot of smaller sides a great chance of stardom.
Marc Roseblade is a Contributor for Bleacher Report as well as Not Just Scottish Football and youth development reporter for Ayr United Football Academy. All quotes are obtained first-hand unless otherwise stated.