Few in the game could have put on so dominating a performance.
After his completely lopsided and dominant performance over Winky Wright, options abound for Paul Williams.
Should he return to 147? Campaign at 154? Make Middleweight his new home?
Let's take a look at the potential challengers at each weight.
147
If Paul is to fight at this weight again, it will have to be for big challenges. The reason he moved up in the first place was the lack of potential challengers, and nobody at 147 seems to be calling him out.
Then again, there is one guy that has the guts to step in the ring with Paul at 147, and that guy is...
Shane Mosley
Shane's name has been mentioned as a potential next opponent for Paul Williams. I personally don't think this fight makes much sense for Shane.
Paul is too young, too big, and would simply overwork Shane over 12 rounds. It would be like watching the Wright fight all over again, but at a different weight class.
It is also worth noting that Paul is not a terribly big draw yet, so unless this fight is taking place at Staples Center, it doesn't make much financial sense either.
With that said, Shane will take this fight if he doesn't have a better offer. Mosley is a fighter's fighter, and backs down from no challenge.
Miguel Cotto
No way Arum lets Cotto anywhere near Paul Williams. It would be like the Margarito fight, but with legal hand wraps. Cotto would land the sharper counter blows early, then get steamrolled by the bigger man. This is a nightmare matchup for Cotto.
Those are the only two names being thrown around at 147 for Williams. Margarito is suspended until who knows when, and Mayweather wants no part of Williams.
Mentioning Pacquiao is laughable. Maybe Judah would be desperate enough to sign on the dotted line.
154
This is the weight class with the least amount of high profile matchups for Paul. The Punisher could likely unify and dominate this weight class for years to come, but their are higher profile matchups at 147 and 160.
For this reason, I see Paul only stopping through this weight class for "stay busy" fights. Here are some options.
Sergio Mora
This is an interesting option for a stay busy fight. Mora has a name, and can sell tickets in California. He is not a very hard puncher, and would likely be an easy win for Williams.
The former contender champion has said no to big fights before, though, so there is no guarantee he would agree to this fight.
Vernon Forrest
This fight would be for the Ring Magazine title at 154. Forrest is ranked No. 1 and Williams No. 2. This fight would be similar to the Wright fight, with maybe an earlier ending.
Forrest is getting long in the tooth, and fights more in spots and has proven against Mora that he can be outworked.
Yours truly ran into Forrest at an ESPN fight in Augusta last year and asked him about a potential matchup with Williams, to which he responded, "Nah Bro, Nah."
James Kirkland
This would be a very interesting matchup. Kirkland is not getting aboard the Paul Williams hype train and has started calling out the Punisher.
He has stated that although Williams is a very good fighter, his tendency to give up his height and fight on the inside makes him an easy target for Kirkland's style. I agree to a degree.
If Williams chose to double and triple up on his jab, circle, and tie up on the inside, this could be an easy win for him.
If he chose to fight on the inside with Kirkland, he could get mauled and outworked. This could be one of the toughest matchups for Williams right now.
Sergio Martinez and Corey Spinks are two other possibilities, and each could present some degree of threat. Martinez is speedy, a southpaw, and can box. He can be easy to hit at times, however, and I'm not sure he could keep up with Paul's work rate.
If he could outspeed Paul and keep moving, he could hand Paul a loss. Spinks is very crafty and always underrated, but he is featherfisted and would likely get beat up.
160
Arthur Abraham
Personally I think this would be a bad matchup for Paul. Abraham has a similar defensive style to Winky Wright, and is younger. He seems to be able to adjust well in fights, and this fight would almost have to take place in Germany to make money.
For these reasons I would favor Abraham in this potential matchup. I'm not saying Williams couldn't win, I just think he has less of an edge against natural middleweights who might be bigger men.
Kelly Pavlik
This fight is likely to be made at some point in the near future. This is a pick 'em fight in my mind. I can see this fight playing out in two ways.
Scenario A is Pavlik catching Williams with some heavy blows and stopping him, or earning a unanimous decision after hurting and dropping Williams. Scenario B is Williams using his angles, footwork, and handspeed to outpoint Pavlik.
I would truly like to see how Williams responds to the power of a hard hitter like Pavlik. He has shown a great chin thus far, but if he keeps moving up in weight someone is gonna be able to test that.
Of all the potential matchups I listed, I see Abraham at 160,and Kirkland and Martinez at 154, as being the biggest threats to hand Williams his next loss.