We are half way through the season, so it is time for a review of what each team has accomplished in the season’s first half.
This year no team has truly set itself head-and-shoulders above the pack (where are you, Texas and Florida?), and parity seems to be the norm for this season (Boise St., Cincinnati, Iowa, and TCU all occupy spots in the top 10). Each major conference has multiple members ranked in the AP poll, and there are still several teams that could vie for a spot in the National Championship game.
Certain teams came into 2009 with sky high expectations (Ole Miss, Rutgers, Ohio St., Ball St., and Oklahoma) and have fallen flat on their faces in the early going, while others have exceeded expectations and made their presence known in the early stages of the '09-'10 college football season (Houston, Pittsburgh, Idaho, Nebraska, and Arizona).
So here we go:
ACC Atlantic Division (Listed by current standings)
Boston College: Record: 5-2 (3-2 in ACC)
Boston College has played solid football throughout the season’s early going. Wins over Northeastern and Kent State were predicted, but a loss against a troubled Clemson squad and a shellacking at the hands of Virginia Tech have hurt the Eagles in the early going. A surprise win against Florida St. and an absolute massacre of NC St. have the Eagles looking optimistically at the season’s second half.
The second half is not overly difficult to navigate, with games against UNC and Central Michigan and trips to Virginia and Maryland in store. Boston College’s biggest test will be its game this week at Notre Dame. Boston College has a five game winning streak against the Irish and continuing that streak on Saturday would not only give the Eagles a win in the “Holy War”, it could also propel them to a strong finish.
Overall Grade: B+
The Eagles will only go as far as their defense can carry them. Their defense has been solid in wins, but was abysmal in the Eagles' loss to Virginia Tech, surrendering 441 yards of offense. The Eagles need 25-year-old freshman wonder child Dave Shinskie to step up in the second half if they have any inclinations of remaining in first in the ACC Atlantic Division.
Clemson: Record: 3-3 (2-2 in ACC)
In Dabo Swinney’s first full year as the head coach of the Tigers, Clemson has seen itself involved in a host of close games. Clemson’s three losses have been by a combined 10 points against Maryland, TCU, and Georgia Tech.
Wins against Middle Tennessee St., Boston College, and a good Wake Forest team have been solid victories in which the stalwart defense has kept opponents in check.
The second half does not look favorable for Clemson. Road games at Miami and South Carolina are treacherous, while home dates with Florida State and a resurgent Virginia team could dispel any dreams Clemson has of playing in the ACC championship game. Kyle Parker needs to get more comfortable in the passing game to take pressure off all-world talent running back C.J Spiller.
Overall Grade: B-
Clemson knew coming into the season that it would have to win early on in the schedule to go bowling. The loss against Maryland was bad, just bad. The second half is imposing and does not play out well for the Tigers. Clemson’s 11th ranked defense will have to carry the load down the stretch, and Spiller will have to get more involved if Clemson is to see the postseason.
Wake Forest: Record 4-3 (2-2 in ACC)
Wake Forest has had a solid opening slate of games with wins against Stanford, NC State, Elon, and Maryland. Quarterback Riley Skinner has been efficient in the early going for the Demon Deacons and has been the ACC’s third most proficient passer, responsible for 251.1 yards per game.
A beating at the hands of Clemson is Wake Forest’s lone blemish, as its other two defeats have been close losses against tough Baylor and Boston College teams.
Wake Forest’s second half just sent a chill up and down my spine. Games against Navy, Miami, Georgia Tech, Florida State, and Duke could all spell trouble for the Demon Deacons.
All of their remaining games, minus the one versus Florida State, are against teams with .500 or better records. Wake Forest will struggle to find footing down the stretch, and Wake may be missing out on some action during the winter.
Overall Grade: B-
Wake has not played poorly in a game, except for its foray against Clemson. The defense has been mediocre and kept the Deacons in games, while Skinner and receivers Marshall Williams and Chris Givens have played admirably in the early going. Skinner and co. will have to keep the pressure on to secure a spot in a bowl game.
Maryland: Record 2-5 (1-2 in ACC)
Maryland has been downright bad in the early going. Barely escaping with a win against FCS James Madison and a loss at home against Middle Tennessee are absolutely incorrigible.
The only bright spot on Maryland’s opening record is its win over Clemson. The Terps' defense has been awful, allowing rushers to average over four yards per carry and allowing 377 yards per game.
The Terrapins remaining schedule is just as damning as the opening slate. Games against NC State, Virginia Tech, Florida State, and Georgia Tech could mean Maryland will end the season with a 2-9 record. Maryland will need to pull itself together down the back stretch to salvage any respectability for this lost season.
Grade: D
The win against Clemson saves Maryland from completely failing, and this is also a rebuilding season for the once-proud Terrapins squad. Losing 30 seniors to graduation is always going to hurt a program, but barely beating FCS opponents is awful, and losing at home against Middle Tennessee State is bad for all involved.
Ralph Friedgen may find himself on the hot seat this off-season. Friedgen has been on the job for nine years and the Terrapins have seen their highs with him at the helm (notably, his first season with Maryland in 2001 when the Terps won the school’s first outright ACC title).
Those days are definitely in the past, and the offensive wizard will need to retool the way he conducts his program.
North Carolina State: Record 3-4 (0-3 in ACC)
NC State may be the kid that sits in the back of the classroom, doesn’t answer any questions, doesn’t do any homework, but is one of the most intelligent kids when he actually contributes to the class. NC State drudged through its early season schedule with wins against FCS opponents Murray St. and Gardner Webb, and losses against everyone else on the schedule (S. Carolina, Wake Forest, Duke, and Boston College).
Those losses are to be expected of the child who takes up space in the back of the class, but the talent the Wolfpack have made an appearance when they handed nationally-ranked Pitt its only loss thus far.
Sophomore Russell Wilson has been impressive in the early going, but the play of the talented underclassman has not led to many victories.
The second half has difficult games against Florida State, Clemson, and Virginia Tech. NC State should be able to taste victory in its battles with Maryland and UNC, but from here on out it is an uphill battle for the Wolfpack.
Grade: D
The child in the back of the room just manages to pass, but is doomed in the upcoming tests. The offense has been mediocre, largely due to an ineffective running game. Coach Tom O’ Brien needs to rework some of the offensive tendencies to get the rushing attack up and moving. The defense also needs to clamp down and give the team the opportunity to stay in the game.
Florida State: Record 2-4 (0-3 in ACC)
Bobby Bowden has seen Florida St. rise to be the talk of college football, and then crumple into a heap just as quickly. A strong game against Miami on opening night and a win at BYU in Week Three had Seminoles fans believing a strong season was in store. But three consecutive losses against South Florida, Boston College, and Georgia Tech have created doubters and questioners.
The Seminoles can put a positive spin on this season with wins over remaining opponents UNC, NC State, Wake Forest, and Maryland. FSU could even throw itself into the division championship with a win at Clemson on Nov. 7. Florida State closes the season with intrastate rival the Florida Gators, and at that point the 'Noles could be playing spoiler or they could be looking at a possible bowl berth.
Grade: D
Up to this point the Seminoles have not performed up to their potential but I believe they are closer to being a one-loss team instead of a four-loss teams. Their largest margin of defeat was against South Florida by 10, and they could have won every game on their schedule thus far.
If Bowden is able to rally the troops, look for him to either make a postseason push, or ruin some other team’s season.