As most of the country focused on two games in Florida Saturday night (Oklahoma at Florida State, Ohio State at Miami), Illinois was quietly winning their first game against a ranked team since 2007. When Nathan Scheelhaase hit receiver A.J. Jenkins in the end zone with less than 10 minutes left following an Arizona State turnover, Illinois grabbed the lead for good.
With this home victory, Illinois stands at 3–0 alongside Wisconsin, Nebraska and Michigan at the top of the Big Ten standings. While this start is a good sign for a coach who seemed to be on the hot seat entering the season, the best magic may be yet to come for Ron Zook and his Illini.
There are at least five reasons why Wisconsin should quickly refocus their attention on Illinois as their primary competition in the Leaders division race. These five reasons explain just why the surprise of 2011 will be Illinois rather than Nebraska or some other Big Ten team.
1. All or Nothing History
Since 2001, Illinois has finished with a winning record only twice. Both times, the Illini made a BCS bowl. Although both of those attempts ended in losses to LSU in the 2002 Sugar Bowl and to USC in the 2008 Rose Bowl, at least Illinois made the biggest stage in college football.
Every other season, Illinois has finished with a losing record, except for last year when a 6-6 record netted a bowl appearance in the Texas Bowl. Considering Zook led the Illini to a dominant win in an essentially road environment versus Baylor, signs looked good for continued improvement this season.
Once again, Illinois is breaking out all at once, and the bounces could go their way just like in 2001 and 2007. Illinois does not have a history of competing well and falling short. When Illinois is good, they are really good.
Ron Zook was backed against the hot seat once before in 2007 after struggling in his first two seasons at Champaign. Then, he rode a solid defense and a sophomore quarterback Juice Williams to nine wins and the Rose Bowl. Zook once again has a good sophomore quarterback and will be looking to knock himself off the hot seat.
And this team has the defense to make the unexpected run to the top once again. Which brings us to point No. 2...
2. The Illini Defense is Strong and Opportunistic
Vic Koenning immediately improved the defense in his first season at Illinois last year, dropping the yards per game from 403 to 351 and points by a touchdown from 2009 to 23.5 points per game. When put in combination with an offense that is now putting up a consistent 30 points per game, that type of defense is enough to carry the Illini to a lot of wins.
Most projected a small step backwards in defense this year with five new starters, four of which were on the line and at the linebacker level. However, the new starters have shown in three games that they can handle changing schemes from Koenning while producing a lot of pressure on opposing quarterbacks when necessary.
Arizona State's quarterback Brock Osweiler entered last Saturday's game in the top 10 nationally in passing efficiency after carving up a solid Missouri defense in Week 2. Yet Koenning came up with a gameplan to apply constant pressure to young Osweiler to prevent him from winning the game with his throwing ability, and the gameplan worked.
The Illini defensive front produced six sacks and 12 tackles for loss, which led to all three of Osweiler's turnovers. Sophomore linebacker Jonathan Brown had a coming out party with 3.5 tackles for loss, 1.5 sacks, and an interception.
If the defense is good enough to stop Arizona State, then the unit is good enough to beat most of the offenses in the Big Ten, especially considering the struggles of teams like Michigan State and Ohio State on that side of the ball. Which leads nicely to point No. 3...
3. The Leaders Division is Wide Open
Illinois was projected to scuffle at the bottom of the division this season alongside Indiana and Purdue. Those projections were correct for the two Indiana schools, as Purdue struggles with injuries again and Indiana has a lot of rebuilding to do under new coach Kevin Wilson. However, the projection for Illinois appears dead wrong.
More importantly, two of the three teams projected to battle it out for the division title have shown huge weaknesses in the first quarter of the season. Penn State cannot find a quarterback that will play consistently decent, let alone good. The ineptitude of the Nittany Lion offense was on full display against Alabama, where Penn State stayed close only because of their solid defense.
Similarly, Ohio State struggled to generate points against Toledo and then were absolutely blasted by an athletic Miami defense this past weekend. Ohio State also has a quarterback conundrum, as senior Joe Bauserman has now thrown up two bad performances in a row. When an offense generates 13 passing yards in the first 59 minutes of a game, that shows every other team exactly how to stop the offense (e.g., stop the run).
With Ohio State and Penn State falling out of the picture thanks to inept offenses, the door is open for Illinois to compete. The Illini have a defense perhaps on par with Penn State and Ohio State, but they are a better team thanks to having a real offense. The key to that offense is the fourth point...
4. Nathan Scheelhaase is Ready to Shine
Scheelhaase made some rookie mistakes in his first season last year, but he was able to lean on conference MVP running back Mikel Leshoure to do most of the heavy lifting. Nonetheless, Scheelhaase added 868 rushing yards of his own to go with 1,825 passing yards.
Perhaps the best sign of progress was that Scheelhaase only threw eight interceptions while accounting for 22 total touchdowns with his legs and his arm. That kind of production was more than enough to win six games, and he has clearly improved this season.
Scheelhaase is on pace to throw for more than 2,000 yards this season, but his bigger contributions in the running game are what will make the Illinois offense tick. Running back Jason Ford and Scheelhaase have led the rushing attack, which has rolled up 223 yards per game so far. As long as Illinois continues to generate over 200 yards per game on the ground, opposing defenses will be open for play action passes, which Scheelhaase has proven he can deliver.
The first time a quarterback faces a set of college defenses, the unusual opposition and defensive looks can undermine the quarterback's natural ability to make the best read. With one game against most of the teams he will face in the Big Ten this season under his belt, Scheelhaase will be a much more effective runner while limiting the amount of big hits he takes.
Assuming that Scheelhaase stays healthy, he should be the difference between being a contender with Wisconsin or struggling like Penn State and Ohio State. Which takes us to the final point:
5. The Schedule is Highly Favorable
In my Big Ten preview a few weeks ago, I identified the schedule as a primary reason Illinois could be a dark horse conference title contender. Now more than ever, that schedule looks like the ticket to Indianapolis for the inaugural Big Ten Championship.
Illinois misses three of the top four teams in the Legends division, as only Northwestern, Minnesota and Michigan are the cross-over games. The road schedule is the easiest in the conference, with Indiana, Purdue and Minnesota joining the only moderately tough game at Penn State. Unless the Nittany Lions find an offense, there should be no excuse for losing a game on the road.
Which leads to the home schedule, which features the rivalry against Northwestern, Michigan, Ohio State and Wisconsin. Northwestern is always tough, but this will be Dan Persa's first game back, which is not a good situation for a shaky Wildcats team. Ohio State has always struggled with good Illinois teams, and even though the Buckeyes will be back at full strength, this is a winnable game.
Michigan and Wisconsin come on back to back November weekends following the bye, and Illinois should be able to figure out how to stop the shootout with Michigan this time around. By the time Nov. 19 rolls around, Illinois should be ready for the Badgers. Wisconsin probably has a better team, but they have not been tested, especially not on the road. If Illinois can stuff the run and keep the home crowd momentum behind them, Illinois can shock the Badgers to steal the division.
The writing is on the wall for the Illini, and this is the right time for them to take another step forward. Illinois has all the look and the intangibles that usually lead to a conference championship, so why not 2011? Get ready, Illinois fans, this should be a wild ride if nothing else in the first year of the Leaders division.