It appeared to be one of the Miracles of the 2010 NFL Season. No, I’m not talking about the 7-9 Seattle Seahawks winning a division title and hosting a playoff game.
And no, it’s not Michael Vick, a modern day gridiron Lazarus leading the Philadelphia Eagles into the playoffs.
For three weeks, Tennessee Titans Head Coach Jeff Fisher, with more than an assist from General Manager Mike Reinfeldt, was somehow able to convince Titans longtime owner Bud Adams that in spite of a 6-10 season record, and a team that imploded after a 5-2 start, that retaining Fisher and releasing Houston favorite son QB Vince Young was the fastest way back to a Super Bowl, a destination the Titans have failed to reach since the turn of the century.
Yes this is the same enigmatic Vince Young, 2006 NFL Rookie of the Year, the franchise QB leader in career winning percentage (minimum 40 starts with apologies to Warren Moon, and Steve McNair) that over his five year stint with the Titans could be credited with salvaging two seasons and perhaps Jeff Fisher’s job after some horrendous starts.
That Vince Young would not be back was not entirely surprising in light of the season ending off field developments. However that Jeff Fisher was being retained …well somewhere, Floyd Reese must have been scratching his head.
Forget Ryan and the Jets! Where was HBO when this football dramatic comedy unfolded? To be sure the season finale was predictable.
When an injured and frustrated Vince Young exploded in the Titan locker room in the aftermath of the Washington game it gave Team Fisher the OFF THE FIELD screen game it needed to rid themselves of a QB they never wanted or grew tired of and at the same time buy the media savvy coach one and possibly several more seasons with this team.
That smoke screen, in contrast to the Titans ON THE FIELD screen game, worked to perfection for Team Fisher.
GM Mike Reinfeldt was clearly in Fisher’s corner. And why wouldn’t he be? Once Fisher by some reports expedited the departure of Former GM Floyd Reese and secured the position as the guy in charge of player/personnel issues, Reinfeldt, a finance guy whose strong suit is not the player personnel arena, was brought in to “work with” Jeff Fisher.
Firing Fisher would have meant that Adams would have to hire a GM/Director of Personnel AND coach, OR hire a Head Coach who would have the same broad discretionary powers that Fisher was granted.
Most of those guys in the latter category are sitting in front of network television prompters on Sundays and Monday nights. And they don’t come cheap.
On the other hand, with Fisher having only one year left on his contract and the impending possible CBA debacle, it appeared that Adams had decided to hold his hand for at least one more year on the Fisher issue.
It was no wonder that Bud Adams very adroitly announced that he was reviewing both issues separately.
There was nothing to be gained in an already polarizing situation by saying he is choosing between a coach who has not won a playoff game since the 2003 season and a winning QB who at the same time can be his own worst enemy.
Few will come to the defense of a player who embarrasses his head coach in the way that Young did even if some of the reasons for his frustration may be valid. This was the trump card that Fisher held and he played it to perfection.
The Vince Young issue was very personal to Jeff Fisher. He wanted Young out, and he was willing to expend whatever political capital necessary to achieve that end.
However smoke screens are extremely vulnerable to changing wind currents. Once the Young issue was resolved, Fisher’s record and the future of the team became the focus. That’s not good if you’re a coach in Fisher’s situation.
The last thing that Fisher wanted was a forensic analysis of his recent coaching performance. There are not enough specimen slides in the CSI and NCIS laboratories combined to document the pathology.
The stark truth is that one does not need a microscope to diagnose the many maladies afflicting this team under his recent stewardship.
Five-game losing streaks in five of the last seven seasons, an undisciplined team that has climbed the NFL leader boards in penalties, curious personnel decisions such as the firing of running backs coach Ernest Byner after two record setting seasons by Titan runners, Randy Moss (enough said), and a defense, a purported strong suit of Fisher's, that has undergone a titanic collapse (pun intended) over the past two seasons.
The Titans have failed to win a playoff game during a time span in which 65% of the league has accomplished that feat.
In the age of instant media and the information superhighway, Fisher’s coaching record has probably been googled more often than Jenn Sterger over the past four weeks.
“Flush the Fish”, “Fry the Fish”, “the Floundering Fish” , Coacho Ocho Ocho, were all remarks on Titan internet chat boards attributed to the coach who was mockingly and at the same time affectionately known as Field Goal Fisher for his conservative ( to be polite) offensive philosophy for most of his tenure in Nashville.
Titan fans came to realize that a more aggressive varied offense is seen in two scenarios…when the defense is so poor that there is virtually no chance to win without attempting to actually score touchdowns (circa 2004) or when the season is virtually over with no chance to make the playoffs.
Was that Damien Williams running that “gimmicky” wildcat against the Colts in the last game of the season?
In spite of all of the above it appeared that Fisher was on his way back. That is until the other shoe dropped. The season finale to Tennessee Titan Survivor was just beginning.
Over the past two weeks, highly regarded long time defensive line coach Jim Wasburn turned in his headset to fly with the Eagles in Philadelphia. Quarterbacks coach turned running backs coach Craig Johnson sailed north to Viking land.
It became apparent that Wasburn and others, including veteran players, were not happy with the way the defense was being handled by defensive coordinator Chuck Cecil.
And Johnson, who had groomed former Titan great Steve McNair and was largely responsible for Vince Young’ s recent progress on the field, was not entirely happy to relinquish his position last year to a guy that had never held a QB coaching position.
It would appear that the straw that broke the camel’s back however was Fisher’s staunch resistance to replacing Chuck Cecil as defensive coordinator, a move he ultimately had to make, and reports that he wanted to hire his son Brandon as a Special Assistant to the team against Adam’s wishes and hiring policies.
It also recently came to light that Fisher had awarded his friend, Chuck Cecil , a guy who was clearly on the hot seat, with a golden parachute one-year contract extension in December.
It is not clear whether that closely kept decision was ever made known to Titan upper management, including Bud Adams.
And so yes, a 17-year coach whose team has managed only six playoff appearances in a league known for parity, and whose crowning achievement was an exciting but failed Super Bowl appearance made possible by a great special teams play, seemed poised to return again with promises of bringing elusive glory to a starved franchise and fan base.
This time, however, there were just too many flags on the field.