How Should Bolton Wanderers Spend Their Money?
With Nicolas Anelka—arguably Bolton's only world-class player—having walked out, £15 million has walked right back in and the Wanderers seem to be at a crossroads yet again.
Anelka's exit was doubtless, but his leaving now puts the Bolton Wanderers in a bad position, unless the money made on his transfer is put to good use. But to what use?
The midfield and forward lines are stacked with players high on perspiration but completely bereft of inspiration, creativity, or any semblance of fearsome attack. The backline is nothing if not porous, coupled with a ‘keeper who will be on his way out by the end of the season—if not sooner—to FC Barcelona or Tottenham Hotspur.
Further complicating matters, Gary Megson is not only short on gravitas and experience with big name players, but there is no guarantee that he will be around past the end of this season.
Gary Speed has also departed and Ivan Campo is not likely to be at the Reebok at the end of next summer. Stelios is not himself and may never be again as Father Time marches on. Plus, it is now clear that Ricardo Vaz Te will never live up to the potential he has shown in years past; he often is fatally unsure when presented with the chances he craves.
So would it be correct to classify Bolton as a club in crisis? Probably. It seems the club requires a broad and deep and thorough cleaning. The momentum gained under the stewardship of recently sacked Newcastle manager Sam Allardyce must be restored, as standing still is akin to reversion in the Premiership.
But, with all of the above in mind, where to spend the Anelka money?
It should be noted that Sammy Lee was not able to spend all available funds this summer, and now an extra £15 million has just come into the coffers. A £6 million bid for Djibril Cisse was rejected and reabsorbed, and the sale of Faye to Newcastle for £2.5 million came on the last day of the transfer window and was, consequently, never spent. To be pedantic you might also add the £250K that came in as Gary Speed departed, taking the total potential transfer kitty to a respectable £23.75 million.
So where does Bolton really suffer? How should this money be spent? As has been reported widely and as the keen observers of any successful side can attest, the spine of the team is most important.
With Jaaskelainen certain to move, a gamble may need to be made on Ali Al Habsi. His performance against Bayern Munich is still fresh in some minds and so the replacement may already be seriously considered. As a ‘keeper similar to Jussi, the transition would be seamless for the Omani who is rated as the best in Asia.
An interesting alternative may be to make a shrewd move to place a swap bid for the Tottenham and England glove man Paul Robinson. If the former England number one can regain his confidence it may prove to be a very strong maneuver. More to the point, Juande Ramos would love to see the back of the player who has cost his team so many points, and along with Rijkaard he has shown interest in Jaaskelainen.
The defensive line is weak across all four positions. There were howls of derision when Andy O’Brien was purchased from Portsmouth but he has proven to be the best defender on the books. Michalik, for all his elevation, is too slow for the Premiership. Nicky Hunt and the converted Joey O’Brien and Ricardo Gardner join Jloyd Samuel as fit for the Premiership, but only in spurts as poor concentration, hapless positioning, and careless distribution make them unsuited to the top flight.
Complicating the issue of defenders is their adaptation to positions from midfield, certainly stunting the development of Joey O’Brien and demonstrating that Gardner was no longer the club's first choice left sided midfielder.
So should Gardner be shown to the door and Joey reinstated to the holding role? The decision is still open to debate, and surely Megson is in discussions with Assistant Manager Archie Knox.
Even if the underrated Andy O’Brien remains in the back four and Meite comes back from the African Cup of Nations unscathed, the duo are the central pairing to have conceded far too many goals this season. Add to that the Frenchman Cid who has not settled well at all and who is rumored to be headed back to France, and it may be argued that at least four new defenders are needed just to keep Bolton in the top flight.
But this move is less likely to occur in this window than by the end of the summer transfer window, Premiership status pending of course. Players who provide a no frills delivery of their trade should be the order of the day and Tottenham has one such man in Paul Stalteri. The Canadian can play on the left and the right full back positions and so should be at the top of Bolton’s list, unwanted as he is by Juande Ramos at Spurs. He will cost no more than £1.5 million, a true bargain.
Another player who may just be able to be snared is the much maligned Phillipe Senderos at Arsenal whose time at a big club is surely at an end as he still wants for pace.
At least one central defender needs to be purchased and preferably one who can lead the line. O’Brien and Meite are both secondary defenders not as adept at organizing the defense as their positions in the Bolton line up suggest. The decline in Meite’s game since Faye departed has been alarming and he is clearly not ready to be the defensive rock that Bolton craves, so a replacement is urgent here. Plus, the midfield has been creaking under the strain of so many aging holding midfield players.
In an attempt to give width to the side Sammy Lee brought in Daniel Braaten and Christian Wilhelmsson, but neither has really demonstrated their worth to the club. On-loan midfielder Mikel Alonso and Wilhelmsson are both expected to be sent back when their loan deals expire.
When given his chance, Andranik Teymourian proves his value, but has been largely ignored so far this term, to the exasperation of many fans. Kevin Nolan has been given the opposite treatment: despite his poor performances he plays week in and week out. If Newcastle is still willing to sanction his purchase for £5 million then Bolton would be foolish not to try and be rid of him in as fast as is possible without offending the club captain.
So creativity is clearly needed and the young Swiss midfielder Blerim Dzemaili may provide it once back from injury, though he has yet been untested. Width may also remain a problem, though with Megson’s aversion to playing anything but direct and simple football, this may not be an area that needs to be urgently addressed. Good distribution is needed as Campo is sure to depart and McCann is often injured and, more disturbingly, dreadfully slow. Cristiano Ronaldo, Joe Cole, Cesc Fabregas, Jermaine Jenas, Nico Krancjar, and Xabi Alonso all provide the spark in midfield for their clubs and it is this spark that is clearly missing from the Bolton line up.
One player who does provide energy and guile is Guthrie, but his performances have shown Liverpool that they may be in possession of the natural successor to Gerrard, out on loan. He is still raw, but at such a tender age he does have plenty of years to improve. It is unlikely that Guthrie will stay at the Reebok, but he should be sounded out to make his loan from Liverpool a permanent move.
If Guthrie is not available then the under-utilised Steve Sidwell at Chelsea should be an ideal candidate, as should Tom Huddlestone at Spurs, to revamp the holding midfield role. The left side of midfield, and possibly defense on occasion, appears to be Matty Taylor at Portsmouth who, along with Pedro Mendes, may be solid purchases providing better options than what is available currently.
Potential loanees may also include Gilberto (if he is not sold to Juventus), and Denilson and Diarra from Arsenal who are both young, talented, and not getting enough game time. Australian Jason Culina at PSV Eindhoven has been searching for a Premiership club for some time and, before his exile to the base of the midfield, was an efficient playmaker who scored goals on occasion.
Bolton’s striking options are severely lacking in goals and all are victims to the parsimonious service from the stale midfield. While Anelka is sure to thrive at Chelsea where he will be given the support to take his season tally well over 20 goals, the Bolton striking options would be lucky to score another 20 goals combined before the end of the season.
Pre-Anelka, the Bolton team was very good at sharing goals and it had been quite some time since a striker scored more than 10 goals. The midfield in Nolan, before his form collapse, and Campo and Speed has always contributed heavily to the Bolton cause. Former defenders in Jaidi and N’Gotty also scored their fair share.
It has been the reliance on Anelka to score that has papered over the cracks at the Reebok.
Elmander and Zigic have both recently been mentioned, as has the scorer of the winner for Blackburn, Jason Roberts. Roberts, as the cheapest player of the trio, is the most likely, and Elmander is rumored to have been valued by his club in recent days at an obscene £22 million. Old boy Eidur Gudjonsson has been desperate to put his Spanish adventure behind him and a possibility for a loan should not be out of the question. West Ham has made their interest in him known and the rumor mill has put Henrik Larsson firmly back in position for another loan move, similar to his stint at Manchester United last season.