TCU Still Title Contender Despite Shaky Win, but Boykin's Heisman Hopes Take Hit

TCU's 23-17 road win over Minnesota in front of a rowdy crowd at TCF Bank Stadium on Thursday night is going to wind up like a fine wine: It'll age well.
Unfortunately for Heisman hopeful Trevone Boykin, his season-opening performance went down like a flat soda.
The fifth-year senior and front-runner for college football's top award had an aesthetically pleasing box score, accounting for 338 total yards and two touchdowns, but a deeper look showed he was rusty.
While the award can't really be lost (or won, for that matter) in one game, Boykin did nothing to prove he was the nation's top player in a game everybody was watching on opening-night, prime-time television.
Instead, he sputtered along with the rest of TCU's offense against a better-than-advertised Minnesota team. Boykin misfired on at least six different occasions to wide-open receivers—two of which would have gone for touchdowns.
On the last one, Shaun Nixon made an impressive double move on a Golden Gophers defender, and nobody stood within 10 yards of him as he raced unimpeded into the end zone. Boykin overthrew him by three feet.
The other time, Emanuel Porter found a seam in the zone, and Boykin—who finished 26-of-42 passing—threw high and behind his target. He immediately lowered his head, angry at himself for the squandered opportunity.
It was a night full of them, and not just for him. TCU's red-zone offense was forgettable.
Boykin had some moments of brilliance, such as a 19-yard touchdown run in the first half where he juked star cornerback Eric Murray on his way to an untouched score. Also, when given time to set his feet and read through his progressions, he delivered some Heisman-caliber throws.
But other times, he suffered from happy feet under pressure, tossing one poorly thrown interception and narrowly missing another one. He also fumbled a pitch under duress, but the Frogs recovered.
The pick in particular was a momentum-flipping mistake.
In a game that many folks wanted to see TCU dominate considering it doesn't play a schedule that will mount much resistance, coach Gary Patterson's team just kind of plodded along.
Even so, this has the makings of morphing into a quality win once some games flow by and we go deeper into the season.
Gophers coach Jerry Kill has built a pretty solid Big Ten team, and while the dearth of playmakers on the offensive side of the ball will keep them from being any kind of contender in the conference, it's not out of the question they could be the class of a weaker West division.
Everybody already knew they boasted a strong secondary, but the front seven looked like a tough, physical group Thursday, too.
Perhaps the biggest positive TCU should take from all this is how it battled respectably in a game that wound up tougher than many thought it would.
Did the Frogs look good winning? No. Did they earn any style points that will help them with the voters and, eventually, the committee? Nope.
But this is a TCU offense that ran roughshod through the Big 12 a season ago, and it returns 10 starters. Though Boykin didn't look like a star against the Gophers, he is one, and he and that side of the ball will get things going.
Defensively, there were serious question marks after the Frogs lost six of their top seven tacklers off last year's team and were without sack leader James McFarland in the opener. But that young group rose to the occasion, thwarting Minnesota at nearly every turn.
The performance was spoiled somewhat by a frenetic fourth-quarter drive the Gophers punctuated with a touchdown, but the TCU defense still impressed. That's a major building block for a season that could wind up being special despite a bit of a stumble over the first hurdle.
Around water coolers all over the country Friday, people will be discussing how the Frogs are overrated, maybe not a serious title contender and how Boykin will have to play his way back into the Heisman conversation.
As for Patterson, he was just happy with a win in a difficult environment.
Games like this one will make a team battle-tested, build character and prepare it for major conference battles down the road much more so than a 50-point cakewalk would. Teams such as Kansas State may force TCU to grind it out, and now it has experience doing so.
TCU and Boykin didn't impress everybody Thursday night, but they could have learned some things that will help them as they embark on this title run.
If that's the case, they will look back on this gritty brawl of a victory fondly.
Brad Shepard covers college football for Bleacher Report. Follow Brad on Twitter, @Brad_Shepard.