MLB Execs Name Giants Biggest Surprise, Orioles Biggest Disappointment in New Report

Just over one month into the 2025 MLB season, the San Francisco Giants and Baltimore Orioles are on opposite ends of the vibes spectrum, and people within the league have taken notice.
In a poll of 20 front-office executives conducted by MLB.com's Mark Feinsand, the Giants were voted as the biggest surprise so far this season and the Orioles were deemed to be the biggest disappointment.
San Francisco received eight votes, finishing ahead of the Athletics (five), Chicago Cubs (three) and San Diego Padres (three). The New York Yankees were the only other team to receive a vote.
The Giants, who won between 79 and 81 games in each of the past three seasons, are currently tied with the Cubs for the fourth-best record in the NL (19-13).
"They’re playing really well in a tough division," one American League executive told Feinsand. "The pitching has exceeded expectations, and Jung Hoo Lee has been a catalyst."
Interestingly, the Giants have done this despite their big free-agent acquisition, Willy Adames, being voted the biggest disappointment among players so far. He is hitting .218/.298/.306 and is tied for 151st out of 164 qualified position players in FanGraphs' wins above replacement (minus-0.4) after signing a seven-year, $182 million contract in December.
The driving force of San Francisco's success thus far has been pitching. The staff ranks fourth in the NL in ERA (3.64) and fWAR (3.9).
Pitching is also a big reason the Orioles are atop the most disappointing list and at the bottom of the AL East with a 12-18 record. Their 5.47 team ERA ranks ahead of only the Miami Marlins (5.89).
The Orioles were overwhelmingly the top choice in the most disappointing category. They received 12 votes, nine more than any other team.
One NL executive explained voting for the Orioles:
"I thought the lineup would carry them, even if the rotation was just OK. But injuries to the rotation and underperformance by most of the remaining starters have been too much to overcome, especially given that a number of their position players—[Gunnar] Henderson, [Heston] Kjerstad, [Tyler] O’Neill and [Adley] Rutschman have struggled as well."
Baltimore is one of three teams with a starting staff that has a collective ERA over 6.00, along with the Marlins and Colorado Rockies. The Rockies (6-25) are on pace to be worse than the 2024 Chicago White Sox.
Compounding the pitching issues is that Gunnar Henderson, Tyler O'Neill and Heston Kjerstad have all been below-average hitters by OPS+ so far. Adley Rutschman and Jackson Holliday are over the average threshold, but just barely.
The Orioles were widely criticized for not being aggressive to add pitching in the offseason, especially after losing key contributors like Corbin Burnes and Anthony Santander.
Baltimore's biggest pitching expenditure was a one-year, $15 million deal for 41-year-old Charlie Morton. He has more earned runs allowed (28) than innings pitched (26.2) so far this season.
One benefit of the MLB season being 162 games is that the standings now don't necessarily indicate what they will be in September.
On this date last year, for instance, only three of the six eventual division winners were in first place. The Houston Astros were tied for the second-worst record in the AL, ahead of only the White Sox. They went 77-53 the rest of the way to win the division.