Booking CM Punk's Return to AEW Amid Swirling Rumors

It's been just over eight months since CM Punk defeated Jon Moxley at All Out and gave All Elite Wrestling an ill-timed black eye in the form of a post-match tirade in the subsequent media scrum.
Ever since, wrestling fans have been inundated with the latest updates on the drama surrounding the polarizing star and his status with the company. Although we've heard our fair share of gossip and tidbits about backstage happenings, most viewers have been clamoring for the less-forthcoming answers.
No matter what side you fall on in online debates or conversations among friends, the consensus is that this was embarrassing for AEW. So much so that most of us want to move on and return to our regularly scheduled programming.
We may finally see a resolution as the former AEW world champion could return for the June 21 episode Dynamite in his hometown of Chicago, according to Fightful Select (h/t Ian Carey of Wrestling Observer). This seems the likely conclusion to this sordid incident and the best destination for his second return.
AEW President Tony Khan could use as many high-profile names as possible ahead of All In London at Wembley Stadium on August 27. There are also rumors that All Out will take place at the United Center this year, where The Second City Saint debuted in 2021.
So, what's next for Punk after a rocky year with the company? Many fans would like to see CMFTR face off against The Elite after the controversial trios match on Nov. 23, 2022. How can we get there?
A Clean Slate
It's difficult to determine how the 44-year-old should re-enter the fray because it's hard to predict how the live crowds will react to him. This was a safe bet the first time as the AEW audience welcomed him back with open arms.
However, the core fanbase is understandably divided now because many are loyal to The Elite. Obviously, Punk must address what happened and make it up to the locker room and the viewers.
Conversely, it would be easy to say he should just turn heel, do what he does best, and play into the controversy. For the sake of this article, let's treat him like a flawed babyface for now.
With that in mind, Punk should cut an honest promo on the go-home episode before Forbidden Door and accept Kenta's challenge.
The New Japan Pro-Wrestling Strong openweight champion has been campaigning for a match with him for years. This would be a great way to get Punk on the card for the show he missed last year and appease the fans.
Even more, Kenta should win their showdown with the Go to Sleep, the finishing move the Japanese star invented and then adopted by Punk. It would be a cathartic moment for those still upset with the Chicago native and proof that he is willing to make amends and do what's best for business.
It may seem odd to immediately hand him a loss, but it would go a long way to show he won't come back to the same preferential treatment. That's important because Khan can't just reintroduce him without some sort of apparent repercussion.
Tying Up Loose Ends
This wouldn't make Punk a sympathetic figure, but he can stand to eat a little crow while he works his way back to a confrontation with MJF. AEW has to pick up where the two left off in September.
Revisiting his best feud with the company will remind viewers of what he brings to the table, but this time there's a slight wrinkle. The Straight Edge Superstar should call out Friedman and stake his claim to a title match at All Out.
During their war of words, Kenny Omega appears and interjects. The Elite are amid a conflict with Blackpool Combat Club now, but the Canadian has been thriving as a single competitor again this year. So, it only makes sense for him to go after the world title this summer.
His premise is simple. Omega can rightfully say he has been here all year trying to elevate this company he helped build again while Punk was gone. Furthermore, he doesn't deserve the chance to represent AEW, and if he wins, he will take the title to the Tokyo Dome in January and defend it at Wrestle Kingdom 18.
This would prompt a No. 1 Contender's match for All In London. The winner would face MJF at All Out the following week at the United Center.
This would be a perfect way to tie both shows together and build two matches at the same time. The Best in the World vs. The Best Bout Machine is also a marquee matchup that could help to sell tickets to Wembley and raise interest in the next pay-per-view.
At the event, Omega should dominate for most of the match until Punk cheats to win. This will sow the seeds of a heel turn and leave the door open for The Cleaner to eventually challenge MJF. It also preserves his motivation to become the rightful face of AEW because some fans are bound to root for him and demand comeuppance for his opponent.
After the match, the two get into a heated exchange until FTR separate them, leaving Omega outnumbered. Let the four men stand in the middle of the ring and soak in the dueling chants until The Young Bucks finally come to their friend's aid to complete the staredown.

This would be an excellent time to tease the trios match on a big stage and make some headlines. Punk goes on to unsuccessfully challenge MJF at All Out. AEW can spend the next few months building to CMFTR vs. The Elite and bring it full circle at Full Gear in November.
That will also give us some time to let cooler heads prevail and reach a truce. If it is an untenable situation, there are other options such as a highly anticipated match with Bryan Danielson or a fresh opponent like Adam Cole. Either of them could be his opponent at Full Gear, too.
Pro wrestling is better with Punk in it. Time will tell if it's worth the risk to keep him on the roster after such a public blowup, but there are many ways to use a star of his caliber.