Play the Blame Game: Players, Coaches, or the System?
The NBA has seen a flurry of blockbuster trades and free-agent signings over the past year.
Before the summer, we saw Phoenix acquire Shaq for Marion, Dallas get Jason Kidd for Devin Harris, and Ben Wallace sent to Cleveland.
Then in the offseason, we saw Baron Davis sign with the Clippers, Elton Brand go to Philly, Corey Maggette to the Warriors, and Mo Williams head to Cleveland. The Clippers also got Marcus Camby, while Toronto acquired Jermaine O’Neal, and Houston got Ron Artest for virtually nothing.
This season, we’ve already seen New York trade away Jamal Crawford and Zach Randolph, and the Pistons swap Chauncey Billups for Allen Iverson to free up cap space for the 2010 free-agency bonanza.
Some teams have thrived with their new acquisitions. The Cavaliers have crushed their opponents en route to the second-best record in the NBA (17-3), while the Nuggets have found a defensive identity with Billups and are 13-4 since acquiring him. The Nets (11-8) are a pleasant surprise, while the Rockets have stayed afloat without Tracy McGrady.
Then there are the teams that are struggling with their new players. The Clippers and Warriors have an atrocious combined record 10-32, the Pistons are 7-8 with Iverson, the 76ers are 9-12, and the Raptors are 8-11, which led to the firing of Sam Mitchell. The Mavericks were 2-7 before winning nine of 10, while the Suns were only 11-9 after a four-game losing streak.
These teams were expected to compete in their conferences, but instead we find them searching for answers. Toronto’s answer was the fire their coach, which has only left them with more questions.
So who’s to blame for these teams’ struggles: the players, coaches, or an inadequate system?
Dallas Mavericks (11-8)
Blame: System, Mark Cuban
Most of the blame should fall on Mark Cuban—he traded away the Mavericks' future in Devin Harris and two first-round picks for Jason Kidd and an extra $11 million. He also fired Avery Johnson—after three straight 50-win seasons, a trip to the Finals, and the best record in franchise history.
The Mavericks with Kidd barely have a record over .500, and looked terrible during the 2-7 start. Since then, Rick Carlisle has righted the ship by winning nine of their last 10.
The Mavericks still do not look like championship contenders, simply because Jason Kidd does not fit with the players around him. Kidd has always most effective when surrounded with athletic finishers, such as Shawn Marion, Kenyon Martin, Richard Jefferson, and Vince Carter.
Kidd no longer has that luxury, since Nowitzki and Terry are jump-shooters. Only Josh Howard is athletic enough to finish at the rim in the transition game.
The Mavericks are also a better half-court team with Dirk Nowitzki and Jason Terry running their pick-and-roll. Their half-court offense also allowed them to become a great half-court defense. Kidd, however, is not quick enough to keep up with quicker guards and doesn’t provide enough offense for the Mavericks to survive. Tony Parker said it best when he said he was thrilled to see Devin Harris go, since he was the best defender on Parker.
Mark Cuban is still banking on Kidd to bring a championship, but we can only wonder how good the Mavericks would be if they still had Devin Harris.
Phoenix Suns (12-9)
Blame: System
This one is pretty simple: the Suns aren’t good enough to run a half-court offense and don’t play defense anyways. For the Suns to win, the best defense is a good offense.
Time is running out on Shaq and Steve Nash, and they can only adapt to a new system for so long. Shaq has probably been the best player for the Suns, but he has hurt the number of possessions for the Suns and cannot run the floor with everyone else. Nash’s game is best in transition and pushing the ball.
Neither player is good on defense either; teams have shredded Nash and Shaq on the pick-and-roll, which was evident when Tony Parker and the Spurs beat the Suns in a five-game series win in last year’s playoffs.
Steve Kerr is a smart guy, but he made a mistake thinking that Shaq could be a long-term solution on defense. Kerr should have gone after a younger, more athletic center, such as an Andris Biedrins or Al Horford.
Now Shaq has also compromised the offense, and Phoenix is just struggling to stay in the playoff picture. The Sun is setting quickly, and even Amare Stoudemire might not stick around past 2010.
Detroit Pistons (11-8)
Blame: Player
The Pistons traded for Allen Iverson for his expiring contract to clear up cap space for next season. Still, the Pistons were still expected to be major contenders in the Eastern Conference.
Iverson, however, has not embraced the commitment for Detroit’s system. The Pistons are 7-8 with Iverson in the lineup, and he is clearly disrupting the Pistons' rhythm. He is shooting only 39 percent while turning the ball over three times a game.
Iverson has also played terrible defense on opposing guards—he has allowed big games from Chris Duhon (25 pts, 9 asts), Andre Miller (19 pts, 6 asts), Beno Udrih (18 pts), CJ Watson (17 pts), Rajon Rondo (15.5 pts, 6.5 asts, 2.5 stls), and was torched by Devin Harris for 38 points. It is embarrassing compared to what Chauncey Billups has done to the same guards.
He is also a distraction to his teammates. Shortly after saying he was committed to Detroit’s philosophy, and even joked about his practice incident, he skipped a mandatory practice on Thanksgiving Day.
The Pistons will still make the playoffs, but they are too far behind the Celtics and Cavaliers. This could very well end six straight trips to the Eastern Conference Championship. Iverson will be a one-and-done deal with Detroit, and is not expected to be re-signed.
Philadelphia 76ers (9-12)
Blame: System
The 76ers surprised everyone by making the playoffs last season, and pushed the Pistons to six games. After acquiring Elton Brand, they were supposed to be in the playoff picture and even contend for an Eastern Conference Championship.
However, 21 games into the season, the team isn’t in either picture.
Last season, the 76ers were a great fastbreak team. Andre Miller constantly pushed the ball and frequently found Andre Iguodala for easy baskets. The team’s glaring weakness was interior defense and scoring, and they had hoped that Brand would solve those problems.
While the defense has been adequate, holding opponents to just 95.1 ppg, the offense has completely stalled, averaging only 94.3 ppg. This is due to Maurice Cheeks frequently running the half-court offense to give his defense a chance to set up. However, this system has backfired for several reasons.
Miller was most effective in transition, often scoring on layups or finding open players. Iguodala was most effective in transition, doing most of his scoring on finishing the fastbreak. But both players have had trouble adjusting in the half-court offense.
Iguodala in particular is struggling the most, because he is neither the ball-handler or the shooter for this system. Consequently, his numbers have dropped in virtually every statistical category.
The best system for this team is to mix the transition game to utilize Iguodala, and the half-court offense to utilize Brand. However, it is a new system, so it could take some time for everyone to adjust.
But if there is no visible progress, Cheeks could be the next coach to pack his bags.
Toronto Raptors (8-11)
Blame: Coach
This one is tough, since people believe that Sam Mitchell didn’t deserve to be fired, despite the disappointing start. After all, it was only two seasons ago that he was named Coach of the Year and led the Raptors to Atlantic Division Champions.
They were, however, eliminated in the first round in each of the last two seasons. Last season, the Raptors dealt with a series of injuries that led to a rocky season and a disappointing campaign. They were also severely lacking rebounding and defense, which was exploited during the five-game loss to Orlando.
The Raptors had hoped that Jermaine O’Neal would solve those problems, and Andrea Bargnani would develop more consistency after a disappointing second year. O’Neal is no longer his former All-Star form, but he is playing relatively decent basketball, and Bargnani has improved from last year.
But Mitchell has not shown any consistency or any preach in defense. Over the four years as the head coach, the Raptors have been a good offensive team, but a terrible defensive team. The team did not have a season when opponents averaged less than 97 ppg under Mitchell. This season they are allowing 104 ppg, and clearly they needed a change in philosophy.
The Raptors need a coach that can emphasize the need for defense and consistency without compromising the offense. Sounds like the perfect job for Avery Johnson.
Golden State Warriors (5-16)
Blame: Players
In 2007, Don Nelson led the Warriors to their first playoff appearance in 13 years, and eliminated the first-seed Dallas Mavericks becoming the first number eight seed to defeat a number one seed in a seven-game series. During the 2007-08 season, the Warriors recorded a 48-34 record, but just missed the playoffs.
Don Nelson had turned around a dismal franchise into playoff contenders, which means there was no coaching problem and he had a good system for the Warriors.
Despite losing Baron Davis to free agency, the team named Monta Ellis their starting point guard, signed wingman Corey Maggette, and were still expected to contend for a playoff spot. Instead, the Warriors are 5-16, including a nine-game losing streak.
Part of the blame falls on Ellis, who tried to cover up his embarrassing moped accident. This left the Warriors without a point guard, and has forced Stephen Jackson and Jamal Crawford to fill that position.
Maggette has been a disappointment as well—despite averaging 19 ppg, he is only shooting 41.3 percent from the field. He has been a selfish player, seldom passing the ball, and has been non-existent on defense.
The rest of the blame falls on front office, which refused to give Baron Davis a substantial contract extension. With Nelson supposedly retiring after next season, the Warriors may be fading quickly back into mediocrity.
LA Clippers (4-17)
Blame: System, Coach
It’s not like we expected the Clippers to be good enough to compete for a playoff spot, but few foresaw the team having the second-worst record in the NBA. Many thought Baron Davis could run the offense with Al Thornton, while Camby and Chris Kaman provided interior defense. They acquired Zach Randolph to bolster the interior scoring.
Instead we see very little scoring and very poor defense, despite respectable play from Randolph, Thornton, Camby, and Davis. Coach Mike Dunleavy makes all front-office and coaching decisions, and is only a few years removed from their last playoff appearance.
The main problem is Dunleavy does not have a system that fits for these players. Davis thrives on an athletic running team, but now is responsible for running a half-court offense, which is not particularly his game since he’s not a great shooter and gets many of his points in transition.
Kaman and Camby are also half-court players, so they cannot complement Davis’s style. They also do not provide the interior defense the Clippers need to run anything in transition. Randolph has provided an offensive spark but plays poor defense.
Dunleavy is trying to mix water and oil with his team, so he made it extremely difficult to build any chemistry and find a suitable system that works for everyone. It’ll be interesting to see if the Clippers can develop any consistency to build upon for next season.
Other Really Dysfunctional Teams:
New York Knicks (9-11)
Blame: Front Office, Starbury
Despite trading away Randolph and Crawford, the team has been a surprise under D’Antoni’s offensive system, and could make the playoffs. Overshadowing the Knicks’ success is the Stephon Marbury and the inability of the front office to take care of business earlier.
Charlotte Bobcats (7-14)
Blame: System, Players, Front Office
This team is just really bad. Michael Jordan just can’t seem to find anything to work for this franchise, and Larry Brown isn’t doing much better. There isn’t that much talent on this roster either, so I’m not expecting the Bobcats to go anywhere for a very long time.
Minnesota Timberwolves (4-15)
Blame: Kevin McHale
Kevin McHale single-handedly destroyed this franchise with his Joe Smith fiasco. He left the Timberwolves with no talent to surround Kevin Garnett, and no talent for the future. Bad trades, bad draft picks, bad team.
Oklahoma City Thunder (2-20)
Blame: Everyone
The Thunder could be on its way to making history. The team is on pace to finish the regular season at 8-74, which would beat out the old worst record in NBA history set by the 1972-73 76ers at 9-73. Even OJ Mayo thought it was embarrassing to lose to this team, and Memphis is 6-15.