In Formula One, the most important man you have to beat is your teammate. He is the only man with equal machinery, so it is very easy to make a straight comparison.
Winning or losing against your teammate can change the perceptions of your performance to pundits and fans. Very often, how drivers fare against their teammate can make or break their careers.
This can lead to some very tense driver rivalries, as we have seen with Alain Prost and Ayrton Senna at McLaren. Neither of them wanted to be the driver that finished second whilst watching their teammate gets the awards and plaudits at the end of the season.
When a driver gets heavily beaten by his teammate, it can lead to his confidence and soul being completely destroyed. Remember the difference between Sato and Ide in Super Aguri’s first season; the sheer difference between the pair ended Ide’s career after just four races in 2006.
It is very important, particularly for rookies, not to be beaten badly by their teammates in their first season. Beating their teammates can also launch them to stardom, as we saw with Lewis Hamilton last season.
So far, a lot of the inter-team rivalries haven’t gone the way that a lot of pundits and fans were expecting.
Qualifying is the best way to compare the speed between two drivers; it proves how fast a driver you are. The stats for how often a driver has finished ahead of his teammate can be a bit deceiving at times, as one of the drivers in the team may have retired whilst racing ahead of their teammate which is obviously bad luck, as opposed to being slower than your teammate.
However, here are all the stats you need, along with my reviews on each teammate war, and who has come out on top in each team.
Ferrari
- Qualifying
- Raikkonen 4 Massa 5
- Fastest Lap
- Raikkonen 8 Massa 1
- Points
- Raikkonen 48 Massa 48
Coming into the season, most people expected Massa to flounder without Traction Control. Raikkonen, fresh from being a world champion, would be able to dominate his teammate and take the team lead with ease.
Surprisingly, it hasn’t happened that way. Massa has made Raikkonen’s life very difficult.
There isn’t much separating the pair. In qualifying, Massa definitely has the edge. He is an expert at qualifying and can pull a lap out of the bag when its least expected in any conditions.
Massa’s average grid position is 3.2, compared with Raikkonen’s 3.9 which prove Massa’s edge over a single lap.
In races, Massa has been good as well. On tracks where he performs well, he makes Raikkonen look average. On tracks where Raikkonen excels, Massa has closed the gap and looks a lot more mature and a more in-depth driver than in previous seasons.
However, both drivers have made mistakes in equal measure. Massa spun five times in the British GP, and Raikkonen lost control of his car in Monte Carlo and made a string of errors in Melbourne.
When Massa makes a big mistake, he still struggles to recover. Raikkonen may have made a few errors in Silverstone, but he still managed to get something out of the race.
I think Raikkonen was perhaps expecting it to be easier this season. He has probably been a bit surprised by Massa’s form and perhaps hasn’t had his eye on the ball all the time.
Massa, meanwhile, has matured and become better on tracks and conditions where he has struggled before. Beating Raikkonen to pole in Monaco and performing better in the wet race was a huge breakthrough for Felipe Massa.
The comparative performances of the two Ferrari drivers here shocked a lot of the F1 paddock.
This is the hardest team to decide who has the edge. Both have had highlights and made errors. Overall, Massa has the edge, not only due to his better stats but the fact that he has upped his game this season when everyone expected a Raikkonen whitewash.
Raikkonen has looked a little bit too laid back at times so far and needs to dig deeper to beat his teammate overall at the end of the season. I think Massa has performed at his best more than Raikkonen, and this has been the deciding battle in this teammate war so far.
War winner: Massa is the winner by the thickness of a piece of paper, but Raikkonen is lurking and could easily stamp some authority in the second half of the season.
McLaren
- Qualifying:
- Hamilton 6 Kovalainen 3
- Fastest Lap
- Hamilton 5 Kovalainen 4
- Race
- Hamilton 5 Kovalainen 4
- Points
- Hamilton 48 Kovalainen 24
Due to Kovalainen’s bad luck, it looks like Hamilton has been really giving Heikki a good beating. However, Heikki isn’t that far off Hamilton’s pace.
In average grid position terms, Hamilton is 4.7 to Heikki’s 5.1. That is only a difference of 0.4.
The only track where Heikki was a lot slower in comparison to Lewis in qualifying was in Montreal, where Lewis was 1.2 seconds faster. Everywhere else it has been quite close.
Kovalainen has even managed to beat Lewis on a few occasions. Kovalainen took a very impressive pole in Silverstone by eight tenths over Lewis.
In Turkey, Kovalainen got onto the front row ahead of Hamilton, who was starting on a very light load.
It’s very clear that Heikki has the speed, but there has been some cruel luck (Australia, Monaco and Canada), and maybe Heikki has not being as aggressive as he needs to be.
If Heikki had had a clearer run at times and more luck he could have been giving Lewis a very hard time. I think in the dry, Heikki would have won at Silverstone. If he hadn't broken his front wing on the first lap in Turkey, he had a great chance of winning there, too.
With Hamilton’s difficulties outside of the car this season, he may be very glad that Heikki hasn’t gotten the results he deserves. However, when Hamilton performs at his best, he has more than enough in his locker to stay ahead of Kovalainen.
Lewis was far better in the rain at Silverstone than Heikki. In the first race of the season, Lewis was able to drive away easily from Kovalainen when the pair were leading the race 1-2.
When Hamilton isn’t on the ball, Kovalainen has certainly shown that he has the potential to match and even exceed Hamilton’s pace. However, he does need a few more tenths to really take the game to Lewis and compete for the championship alongside him next season.
War Winner: It looks convincing for Hamilton, but Kovalainen’s bad luck skews that verdict slightly. Heikki is closer to Hamilton than he looks.
BMW Sauber
- Qualifying
- Heidfeld 1 Kubica 8
- Fastest Lap
- Heidfeld 5 Kubica 4
- Points
- Heidfeld 36 Kubica 46
So far this season, Kubica has stepped out of Heidfeld’s shadow and is acting as team leader. Kubica has become a faster, fitter and more consistent driver who doesn’t make many mistakes.
Kubica is a new man this season. He has been very impressive in qualifying.
Kubica’s average qualifying position is 4.2, whereas as Heidfeld’s is 7.8. That is a difference of 3.6. The BMW is comfortably a Top Six car, which is slightly slower than the McLaren and the Ferrari.
Kubica’s average grid slot is very impressive, showing that he has been able to mix with faster cars. In Heidfeld’s case, 7.8 shows that he hasn’t always been able to qualify the car where it ought to be on the grid.
Heidfeld’s biggest problem has been warming up the tyres in order to deliver a great qualifying lap.
In races, Kubica has had the advantage due to qualifying better and got the team’s first win at the expense of Heidfeld.
However, despite Kubica receiving all of the plaudits, Heidfeld has quietly been doing a decent job in races. Despite being battered, he is only 10 points behind Kubica in the championship.
In the two races where Kubica got no points (Australia and Britain), Nick got second on both occasions.
Nick appears to be solving his problems and getting his confidence back. He could end up surprising people and closing in on Kubica later on in the season.
This would be a turn up for the books, considering the superstar praise Kubica has been receiving and the flak Heidfeld inevitably has had to take.
War Winner: Kubica but not by as much as it seems. Just look at the championship table for proof of that.
Toyota
- Qualifying
- Trulli 7 Glock 2
- Fastest Lap
- Trulli 8 Glock 1
Not everyone in F1 rates Trulli highly, so coming into F1, GP2 champion Glock’s task was to beat Trulli to have any chance or progressing further in F1. So far, he has been utterly thrashed by Trulli.
In qualifying, the Toyota is good enough to be in the top 10. Whilst Trulli has done this on regular occasions, Glock hasn’t.
At times, the difference between their grid positions has been quite vast. In Australia Glock qualified 18th, and Trulli was in sixth.
In Turkey, Glock qualified 15th and Trulli eighth. A lot of Glock’s GP2 success last season was built on good qualifying performances, so to be beaten so badly by another qualifying expert is very damaging for him at the moment.
His trump card isn’t anywhere near enough for him against Trulli. In his championship winning year, he qualified on the front row in six of the 11 events, including four pole positions.
In F1, you race where you qualify. As it is so difficult to overtake, Trulli has always had the big advantage in races, with Glock not being able to catch up with him.
The only track where Glock has beaten Trulli in a straight fight is in Canada; incidentally the only track he performed well at in his short time with Jordan in 2004.
Apart from that, Glock has been no match for Trulli. Unless Glock can turn this around, his F1 career will be over. No other team will be interested in a driver being dominated by Trulli on the same team.
In Glock’s defence, Trulli has been inspired this season but that doesn’t stop the fact that Glock should be far closer to him.
With the driver talent about nowadays, Glock may well end up back in GP2 and staying there. You can’t see many signs of Glock improving at the moment.
War Winner: Trulli by miles. Glock will struggle to get a second season in F1 at this rate.
Red Bull
- Qualifying
- Coulthard 1 Webber 8
- Fastest Lap
- Coulthard 3 Webber 6
- Race
- Coulthard 2 Webber 7
- Points
- Coulthard 6 Webber 18
DC suffers a similar problem to Glock in that he has a teammate who is extremely quick over a single lap. This gives Webber the advantage when it comes to races.
Webber has been able to qualify at the front of the midfield regularly this season whereas DC is often in the middle of the midfield, where it is very easy to get bogged down and involved in incidents.
Webber has pulled off a consistent run of points finishes this season. In fact, he has managed six points finishes in a row this season. DC, on the other hand, has been involved in incidents. In clean races, he has had three finishes in ninth place.
Those three races show that he can race very well from lower positions; but when you start between 10th and 20th, it’s very hard to push into the top eight.
If you start in the top eight, which the Red Bull car is capable of, then getting the points is easier. DC isn’t fast enough in qualifying to achieve this same record and get the most out of his Red Bull like Webber can.
Webber has used his qualifying card to convincingly beat DC this season. Webber’s average grid slot is 7.9 and DC’s is 12.2, which proves the theory.
Having said that, DC has actually been in the top 10 more this season than this time last season but still can’t hope to match Webber’s qualifying standards.
Webber has stayed out of trouble and gotten the job done. DC has had a lot of bad luck, and things haven’t fallen for him. F1 is a very unforgiving business, and at the end of the day, it’s a results business. It is Webber that has gotten the results.
In Canada, DC showed how good a racer he is when the circumstances fall for him and nothing goes against him. DC will look back on a lot of successful seasons when he retires. Sadly for him, and for me as a DC fan, this isn’t looking like one of them.
War Winner- Despite bad luck, DC is solid, but Webber has simply been by far the more consistent spectacular performer. He is looking more like a top line driver race by race. DC just can’t match him.
Renault
- Qualifying
- Alonso 9 Piquet Jr. 0
- Fastest Lap
- Alonso 8 Piquet Jr. 1
- Race
- Alonso 8 Piquet Jr. 1
- Points
- Alonso 13 Piquet Jr. 2
This is the teammate war with the biggest gap in performance. Whilst Alonso has been trying his hardest to get every tenth there is out of this season’s off pace Renault, Piquet Jr. has been having a nightmare, struggling to adapt to F1.
Piquet Jr. has never beaten Alonso in qualifying, and the average grid slots tell the story. Alonso’s average grid slot is 6.3 and Pique's is a very poor 13.6. That is quite a difference.
Alonso has only failed to qualify in the top 10 once this season, Piquet has only made it in three times out of nine.
In races, Piquet Jr. has been poor and made errors. Alonso has picked some points up, although he has made mistakes too in good points position. So at least points wise, the gap between the two isn’t massive so far.
If Piquet Jr. doesn’t get closer soon, his career will be in huge trouble. The last man you want as your teammate when you are struggling is Fernando Alonso.
At least Piquet Jr. is showing a few signs of improvement. He capitalized on an error by Alonso to finish ahead of him in France. In qualifying for the British GP, he was only a few tenths slower and in the top 10.
If Piquet Jnr can continue to show some improvement after early humiliation, he stands a chance of getting his early F1 career out of the red danger zone and get another chance next season. However, he can’t afford any more mistakes or slow weekends.
Alonso does need to keep his distance and stay ahead of Piquet. After Piquet’s first half of the season, a lot of potential new suitors for Alonso would raise their eyebrows if Piquet starts closing the gap down to Alonso.
War Winner: Alonso has practically blasted Piquet Jr. with a cannonball, but he needs to be careful he doesn’t relax and let Piquet send it back.
Williams
- Qualifying
- Rosberg 7 Nakajima 2
- Fastest Lap
- Rosberg 6 Nakajima 3
- Race
- Rosberg 5 Nakajima 4
- Points
- Rosberg 8 Nakajima 8
This one is quite intriguing.
A lot of people were perhaps a bit disappointed that Williams took on Nakajima, as he didn’t perform consistently in GP2. Certainly the prediction most seen was that Rosberg would blow Nakajima completely out of the water.
This isn’t completely true. Nakajima has taken a lot of F1 personnel by surprise.
In qualifying, Rosberg has definitely shown he is the driver with more pace. Rosberg has been in the top 10 shootout four times this season, whereas Nakajima has never made it that far.
Rosberg’s average grid position is 11.9 and Nakajima’s is 14.9. Nakajima’s one-lap pace hasn’t been strong, but he isn’t as far back as a few other drivers in comparison to their teammate, i.e., Glock, Piquet Jr. and Coulthard.
The racing comparison is the really interesting part. Nakajima has shown himself to be a solid racer who doesn't make too many mistakes. He has also taken his opportunities when they have come.
He has finished in the points four times to Nico’s three. In the wet conditions in Monaco, Nakajima stayed out of trouble and impressed in seventh place, whilst Nico made a big error and crashed heavily.
In Spain, Nakajima made the most of the rate of attrition and got a couple of points, too. In the treacherous conditions in Silverstone, he did a better job than Rosberg and won another point.
Rosberg is still the faster driver, but in races Nico hasn’t always got the job done and has made a few errors. The Williams isn’t that quick this season, but Nakajima is showing that he is sometimes a match for Rosberg.
When a chance for points comes along, he has taken them. Rosberg hasn’t.
Last season, Rosberg was very convincing against Wurz, but he was a weak teammate. Maybe that made Rosberg look better than he actually is.
This season, Nakajima is proving a tough challenge, and Nico hasn’t been convincing enough to suggest he is one of the top drivers in F1.
I wonder whether he regrets being so committed to Williams when there was a seat with his name on it at McLaren. Will the chance come again?
Rosberg needs to start beating Nakajima more convincingly in the second half the season so he doesn’t disappear off the radar of the top teams. Nakajima has performed above expectations and is securing his place on the F1 grid.
War Winner: Rosberg is currently the quicker driver, but it’s a little too close for comfort, which is raising eyebrows.
Honda
- Qualifying
- Button 4 Barrichello 5
- Fastest Lap
- Button 4 Barrichello 5
- Race
- Button 3 Barrichello 6
- Points
- Button 3 Barrichello 11
These are two drivers in very different situations. Barrichello is fighting for his place on the team, whereas Button feels confident his seat is safe for next season and his mind is probably already on 2009.
When you compare the performances so far, I think the above statement really shows. Button ought to be beating Barrichello comfortably to stake his claim as one of F1’s best drivers, but he isn’t.
If anything, Barrichello has clearly been the better Honda driver. In average grid position, Rubens has the edge. Jenson Button has averaged at 13.6, whereas Rubens is ahead at 13.1.
Montreal is the greatest example of how well Rubens has driven. He qualified ninth, whereas Button couldn’t get out of the first qualifying session.
In races, Rubens has driven very well, too, and has an even bigger edge here points wise. In races where you would expect Jenson to get good points, he has made errors and it’s been Rubens instead who has taken the initiative.
In both this season’s wet races, where you would expect Jenson to excel, he has made a mistake, and Rubens has taken nine points out of those two races alone.
Barrichello also finished seventh in the crazy Canada race, where Button finished only 11th. Rubens should have finished even higher in that race but slipped towards the end.
Barrichello has made more of the equipment and opportunities than Jenson has. Rubens has overall been faultless but Button has made a few critical errors and hasn’t got it together.
If anything, Barrichello is more deserving to stay in the team next season than Button is. Button is showing signs that for this season he is lacking a bit of motivation and perhaps he is taking his place in the team for granted. He needs to up his game considerably.
War Winner: Barrichello has gotten more results for the Honda team and is extracting more from the car than Button. There is life in the old dog yet.
Torro Rosso
- Qualifying
- Bourdais 4 Vettel 5
- Fastest Lap
- Bourdais 4 Vettel 5
- Points
- Bourdais 2 Vettel 5
This was a very highly anticipated team war coming into the season: A multiple champion in America against a very highly rated young rookie.
A lot of hype surrounded Vettel’s performances so far this season, but he hasn’t completely dominated Bourdais as you can see from the stats above.
The average qualifying slot for Vettel has been 14.8 and 16.1 for Bourdais. This suggests that Saturdays, Vettel does indeed have an edge, but not as decisive as we have seen in other teams further up the grid.
Vettel hasn’t obliterated Bourdais as all the F1 pundits have been suggesting.
What has really separated Vettel from Bourdais is that Vettel has shown more moments of star quality, whilst Bourdais has been solid and within the limits offered by his Torro Rosso, but just not spectacularly.
Vettel has been in the top 10 shootout twice this season and scored points in the difficult conditions in Monaco (whilst Bourdais hit the barrier) and again in the difficult Montreal conditions.
It’s these occasions that have made Vettel one for the future, despite the fact he has had a few anonymous weekends and numerous collisions.
Bourdais on the other hand is a driver just fighting for his rights just to stay in the team for another season.
Bourdais needs to up his game in order for people to start taking him seriously. He simply has to take some of the hype away from Vettel and take some praise for himself.
Despite not being dominated by Vettel, as shown by the stats above, a couple of Vettel’s performances are making it appear like he is being dominated.
War Winner: Vettel is definitely ahead of Bourdais overall, but a couple of great results has made him seem further ahead of Bourdais than he actually is.
Force India
- Qualifying
- Fisichella 6 Sutil 3
- Fastest Lap
- Fisichella 6 Sutil 3
- Race
- Fisichella 6 Sutil 3
- Points
- Fisichella 0 Sutil 0
This is a very interesting battle so far. Sutil received a lot of praise for his performances last season and was touted as a future talent.
However most people ignored the fact that he was against very weak teammates in Albers, Winkelhock, and Yamamoto.
Fisichella may have struggled at Renault, but he is always good in slower machinery where he is able to punch above his weight. So far, Sutil hasn’t been driving very well, and Fisichella has made the most of the car.
In qualifying up to Turkey, the average time difference has been around 0.5 to 0.6 seconds in favour of Fisichella. That is a lot of time to be losing to a teammate. This period really damaged Sutil.
However, after a great wet race in Monaco where Sutil showed his talent in the rain, he was running in fourth until being punted out by Raikkonen.
This race has been enough to get people talking about Sutil again and seeing that there is talent there. Since then, Sutil has been level in terms of time with Fisi and has started to get his confidence back.
Over the next few races, he must stay ahead of Fisichella more often to save his chances in his F1 career.
Even if he doesn’t manage that, pundits will remember his drive in Monaco and this may be a saving grace for him even if he doesn’t deserve it. It may prove to be the most important performance of his career.
War Winner: Fisichella has been considerably faster than Sutil for most of the season and made him seem like less of a talent than people had perhaps previously thought. Monaco seemed to influence people otherwise and may be Sutil’s passport to staying in F1.