Susie Wolff Should Not Move Up to Race Seat, but Simona De Silvestro Could Have

Susie Wolff has broken down a lot of barriers in Formula One, and another fell to the Scot at the end of November.
Williams, the team she joined as a development driver in 2012, have promoted her to the position of official test driver for 2015. It's the highest F1 role held by a female since 1992—in the driver hierarchy at Grove she sits third, behind only the two race drivers, Valtteri Bottas and Felipe Massa.
Or at least, she does for the time being.
Having entered the sport in 2012 as a development driver for Williams, Wolff initially worked on the team's advanced simulator. Positive results saw her role gradually expand in 2013 before moving to the next level the following year.
At the 2014 British Grand Prix, Wolff became the first female driver since Giovanna Amati to take part in a grand prix weekend. Taking over Bottas' FW36, she was set for a full Friday practice session before a car failure cut her day short after just one timed lap.
She returned to the car for first practice at the next race, which was held in Germany. This time, the car held together and Wolff was able to do a full programme. She did 22 laps and set the 15th-fastest time—one minute, 20.769 seconds. Felipe Massa, in the other Williams, was 11th with a 1:20.542.
The gap was just two tenths of a second, admirable when one considers Massa is a former championship contender with 39 podiums to his name.
Perhaps in response to Wolff's impressive displays, a promotion arrived at the end of the season.

Formerly a development driver, Wolff was been promoted to be the team's official, seemingly primary test driver. A Williams statement read:
Williams is pleased to announce that Susie Wolff will be stepping up to the position of official test driver for Williams Martini Racing for the 2015 Formula One season.
In this role Susie will be driving the Williams Mercedes FW37 in two FP1 sessions and two test days during the 2015 Formula One season. She will also be conducting extensive simulator testing to help in the ongoing development of the FW37 and FW38.
This new role builds on Susie’s three seasons as development driver for Williams, which culminated in driving the FW36 during FP1 at the 2014 British and German Grands Prix. This saw her become the first female driver to drive in a Grand Prix weekend for two decades. The team is currently evaluating a number of drivers to replace Susie as development driver.
Any promotion is a good thing, and some, including Ian Parkes of the Press Association (h/t Daily Mail), suggest she'll be first in line to step up should Massa or Bottas be forced to miss a race for any reason.
But that isn't the case—nor should it be.

Felipe Nasr, the team's primary tester in 2014, had the title of test and reserve driver. Per the team's statement on his arrival, he was signed up for five test days and three free-practice sessions.
The important word is, of course, "reserve"—indicating the driver who will, officially, be first in line for a race drive should Massa or Bottas be unable to compete.
Williams could have given this title to Wolff, but it was conspicuous by its absence in their statement. That tells us all we need to know about the team's confidence in her and how they see her future.
She's an excellent test driver. A team like Williams would not give up invaluable track time to someone who could not provide useful data.
Those who view her presence as nothing but cheap publicity may never change their opinions, but cheap publicity doesn't make up for useless data. And unless your surname starts with "K" and ends in "ardashian," it doesn't pay the bills either.
Testing-wise, Williams clearly believe Wolff can do as good a job as Massa or Bottas. But when it comes to racing, it's a little bit different.
The Scot hasn't raced single-seaters competitively since 2005. That year, she entered two British Formula Three races, scoring two points.

Aside from those two outings, the highest open-cockpit level at which she has competed is British Formula Renault 2.0. Wolff spent three seasons and scored three podiums, with a best championship position of fifth.
Leaving single-seaters behind in 2006, Wolff drove in the German DTM (touring car) series for seven years, scoring points on just two occasions. She left at the end of 2012, and that was the last time she did any form of competitive racing in a recognised series.
And being a DTM backmarker is nothing like racing in a grand prix.
As I wrote back in July, if Williams had any intention of using Wolff as a race driver, they would be working on giving her relevant single-seater experience. GP3 would be a (relatively) cost-effective place to start and would allow Wolff to be present at every grand prix.
But they aren't doing that because they know she'll never race one of their cars—or any other F1 car for that matter.
That's nothing to do with her gender. Rather, it's because there's no evidence to suggest she'd be any good at it. Her record says everything there is to say. The role of reserve driver will go to someone with a good, recent history in a relevant racing series.
But Wolff is not the only woman on the F1 radar. Until recently, a second female driver was involved with an F1 team.

Simona de Silvestro's time with Sauber came to a quiet, barely noticed end in October as a result of insufficient financial support. The 26-year-old Swiss signed with the team in early 2014 as an affiliated driver with the goal of a race seat in 2015, per Formula1.com. She came over to Europe after four seasons in the IndyCar series.
In the last of those seasons, her team-mate was 2004 IndyCar champion Tony Kanaan. De Silvestro finished 33 points (397 to 362) behind Kanaan in the final standings but had nine top-10 finishes—including a second place—to Kanaan's seven.
It's not the stellar record one might hope for in an F1 prospect, but it does show that De Silvestro is 100 per cent capable of racing near the front at a high level.
That her best performances came on street circuits—not ovals—also stands out.

After her release from Sauber, team principal Monisha Kaltenborn told Autosport that she felt De Silvestro was the only female driver in the world who would be capable of stepping up to an F1 race seat.
And having seen the same records, I'm inclined to agree. After years of waiting, the sport had stumbled across a woman who maybe, just maybe, could have succeeded and, at the very least, held her own as a race driver.
One who was also multilingual, seemingly pleasant and personable and whose name would be recognised in the important United States market.
But instead of being given a reasonable opportunity—a few Friday drives or a proper test in a current car—her disappointing time with Sauber won't even warrant a footnote in F1 history.
Wolff deserves her test role. But the only woman in motorsport who not only wants to be in F1 but also looks halfway deserving of a race seat is probably heading off back to IndyCar, never to return.
Maybe next generation.